Darkdoji wrote: Wed Aug 02, 2023 1:29 am
I will not argue with you I have said what I have said -------------> you are wrong and that closes the chapter for me (rather than going down a road of pettiness that leads no one anywhere). I cannot think of a pedigree trader that does what you did, very unprofessional and again it is very terrible thing in my book misleading traders. If you exclude you mind from your trading then you are not trading. Your mind requires balanced information to make balanced judgements. You are more grown up than to be as childish as a game "but you said"....taken in context I am correct but giving all of that context here whatever I have said over some nonsense is not my understanding of a mature conversation. Nothing more need be added go test the tool in a transparent scheme and come see us again. Right now we are not buying. Got it? Lets be serious on the thread if the aim is to support one another. But if you are seeking a "Gold medal" for your "System" find your Olympics elsewhere. Let us trade folks!
(-_-)
And here is what is very confusing. Right after I posted the entry, you posted, " It is a good trade with good expectations and hope you manage it well - do not jump out due some irrational fear of reversal, . . ." It seems odd that if you had concerns, as you later listed, that you made no critical remarks about anything that I wrote.
But after price failed to continue any significant amount higher but turned into a loss, you scrambled to find a variety of "reasons" why it was not a good trade and that I must have some sinister ulterior motive for even posting.
As far as your other assumptions, they hold no weight (nor truth), because I listed ALL of the criteria that I considered to decide on an entry. And you can see for yourself that it was a quite sparse list. In addition, I gave some commentary on what I was expecting to develop via semaphores with no mention of any other system or indicators: Everything that I mentioned is part of Orbit. IF I would have been using something from another system as part of the entry criteria, I would have included it in the list.
On a related note, I can assure you from my experience in dealing with other traders, especially newcomers, they WILL read the Scalping manual and, as I did, simply apply the listed criteria with no consideration of anything else. They tend to naively think that a document like that is like a cookbook, and only blindly following what is written without any thinking will produce the perfect cake first time, every time.