Hi josi,josi wrote: Tue Jan 04, 2022 7:55 pm I think if it could be done in such a way the indicator signals might turn out to be extremely good.
I make this version, you may try.josi wrote: Tue Jan 04, 2022 7:55 pm I already wrote this to MrTools (about a similar indicator), so don't be angry if I repeat myself here.
It is because I like this indicator but I don't think the signals are very good:
This is meant as a suggestion (and not at all any kind of criticism):
If one takes into account how this indicator works (2 lines crossing and recrossing, tendentially going in opposite directions), a signal whenever the lines cross is
a) almost always too late (because half the move may already be over when lines cross)
b) the bigger the last move, the longer the distance to the next possible cross
The same problem arises if you take zero-cross for signals.
Logically speaking (ideally?) the best point for such an indicator to give a signal is when it has reached extremes (with both lines) and moves away from these extremes.
So one could either think about
a) Stoch-style-level-signals or
b) slope-change-signals (but these would only work with considerable smoothing of the lines).
I think if it could be done in such a way the indicator signals might turn out to be extremely good.
Brilliant work kvak!! Truly amazing skills you havekvak wrote: Wed Jan 05, 2022 11:00 am I make this version, you may try.
Have signal MA and you may choose now 4 logic for coloring.
Also have price smoothing. If you add price smooth = 0. Have nonsmoothing version.
Good or not good...give feedback
Looks good! Clean and easy to read. As long as you follow the trend all is good. I like the use of your Semaphores, Did you just adjust your settings for that? I may do the same:)BeatlemaniaSA wrote: Wed Jan 05, 2022 2:21 pm Brilliant work kvak!! Truly amazing skills you have
It's looking and working great on my charts combined with your 2XMA but I and the rest of the community are looking forward to @josi's insightful and critical feedback which is highly appreciated. Since these were his suggestions
Warmest regards,
BeatlemaniaSA
Hi JonIn,Jonln wrote: Wed Jan 05, 2022 4:00 pm Looks good! Clean and easy to read. As long as you follow the trend all is good. I like the use of your Semaphores, Did you just adjust your settings for that? I may do the same:)
Yes, I do like my charts to be clean and easily readable! I did adjust the settings for the semaphores. I've used XARD's system before but unfortunately you cannot adjust or change the semaphores in XU-12.
It is the same as XARD's semaphores as it is based on the zigzag. Thanks to kvak and mrtools with their amazing coding skills it is much more configurable. So I have 2 Lucky Reversal indicators on the charts. One with a setting of 26 and the other with a setting of 60 (for the final PFH or PFL), i.e the large circle 
Thank you, kvak, very interesting!
Hi guys,BeatlemaniaSA wrote: Wed Jan 05, 2022 4:21 pm In addition to the Lucky reversal indicators I have @kvak's 2xMA, a CCi indicator and @kvak's updated Didi Index smooth indicator. That's it
Questions and suggestions are welcomed.Dear @BeatlemaniaSA,BeatlemaniaSA wrote: Thu Jan 06, 2022 7:17 am Hi guys,
Just a quick update to let you know how I trade using the setup that I provided in my previous post. I hope the moderators won't mind me posting it here. I apologize if it's not in the right thread
...
Code: Select all
<indicator>
name=Custom Indicator
<expert>
name=Didi index(mtf + alerts + lines) modHi Viktor,viklam wrote: Thu Jan 06, 2022 2:08 pm Dear @BeatlemaniaSA,
Thank you for sharing your indicators of your choice, the nice setups and even the "tutorial" on how to take trades based on those indications.
However i've just noticed a-very-minor stuff to update on your template (Didi 2 x MA.tpl) inside the shared "Didi Index 2XMA.zip" package file. Here is what i noticed:
So, if it won't be any trouble, would you be kindly share the most recent TPL for the package.
Thanks in advance.
Best Regards,
-Viktor-
