rsistoch wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 3:26 am Hi Funchi-san, can you add option price is above or below the HMA for FNC-HMA.
TYSM!!

If you set “Ma Period” to “1”, “Ma Applied Price” to “CLOSE”, and “Ma Method” to “SMA”, it will perform the same operation.

funchi wrote: Mon Aug 11, 2025 10:08 pm It appears that FNC_XARD_Signals has not had its bugs addressed as much as FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals.
Since the source code for FNC_XARD_Signals was released, no further updates have been made.

I recommend upgrading FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals rather than FNC_XARD_Signals.
It takes considerable effort to analyse source code created by someone else (in this case, my daughter).

What is the reason that FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals would not work for you?
Or, conversely, what is the reason you prefer FNC_XARD_Signals?
If necessary, I can extend FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals to include the features of FNC_XARD_Signals.

Reasons for Preferring FNC_XARD_Signals
I prefer FNC_XARD_Signals because it offers greater flexibility in selecting signal conditions without restrictions. In contrast, with FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, you are limited to choosing only one Entry/Exit condition (e.g., Trendline Flat, Trendline Opposite, Arrow-Trendline, etc.). The True/False selection options in FNC_XARD_Signals allow me to customize the settings precisely to my needs.
Specific Requirements
My focus is solely on the Dots, specifically:

The 4th Pink Dot with a period of 36.
After an Arrow 144, breaking to the 2nd Dot or 4th Dot, as indicated in the referenced image.
I want to exclude Trendlines or other elements entirely, keeping my strategy centered only on the Dots.

Requested Enhancements for FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals
To make FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals more suitable for my needs, I’d like the following features to be incorporated:

-Input Conditions: Add the flexible input conditions from FNC_XARD_Signals, allowing for True/False selections to customize signal conditions.
-Signal Display Options: Include the ability to select and display Flat/Up/Down(short/Long/Exit) signals.

-Sound Alarms: Integrate pre-set sound alarms from the Sounds folder to accompany the signals.
-Histogram Comment: Retain the Histogram Comment feature from version 1.00 of FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, which displays the trading symbol and timeframe. I find this feature highly practical and valuable.

Final Notes
I hope my explanations, along with the images I’ve sent (both now and previously), clearly convey my requirements. I apologize for the lengthy message and appreciate your patience.
As always, I am deeply grateful for your kindness and support toward me and all members of this community.

iardavan wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 11:35 am Reasons for Preferring FNC_XARD_Signals
I prefer FNC_XARD_Signals because it offers greater flexibility in selecting signal conditions without restrictions. In contrast, with FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, you are limited to choosing only one Entry/Exit condition (e.g., Trendline Flat, Trendline Opposite, Arrow-Trendline, etc.). The True/False selection options in FNC_XARD_Signals allow me to customize the settings precisely to my needs.
Specific Requirements
My focus is solely on the Dots, specifically:

The 4th Pink Dot with a period of 36.
After an Arrow 144, breaking to the 2nd Dot or 4th Dot, as indicated in the referenced image.
I want to exclude Trendlines or other elements entirely, keeping my strategy centered only on the Dots.

Requested Enhancements for FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals
To make FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals more suitable for my needs, I’d like the following features to be incorporated:

-Input Conditions: Add the flexible input conditions from FNC_XARD_Signals, allowing for True/False selections to customize signal conditions.
-Signal Display Options: Include the ability to select and display Flat/Up/Down(short/Long/Exit) signals.

-Sound Alarms: Integrate pre-set sound alarms from the Sounds folder to accompany the signals.
-Histogram Comment: Retain the Histogram Comment feature from version 1.00 of FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, which displays the trading symbol and timeframe. I find this feature highly practical and valuable.

Final Notes
I hope my explanations, along with the images I’ve sent (both now and previously), clearly convey my requirements. I apologize for the lengthy message and appreciate your patience.
As always, I am deeply grateful for your kindness and support toward me and all members of this community.

I have not yet decided how I will proceed, but once I understand the trading procedure, I intend to develop it so that it works accordingly.
I will probably release it as the iardavan version.

Entry alert condition: Appearance of the 4th Dot (36) after an Arrow (144).
Exit alert: Not required.
Only UP/DOWN alerts.
Trendline, candle colour, daily open line, and ADR will not be used for the signal logic.

Is that correct? Or do you sometimes use the trendline, candle colour, daily open line, or ADR?

funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 11:28 am If you set “Ma Period” to “1”, “Ma Applied Price” to “CLOSE”, and “Ma Method” to “SMA”, it will perform the same operation.

i tried doing that but when HMA is green (up) and SMA 1 above HMA then DB will give Flat signal, because FNC HMA logic is HMA is above or below MA. i need the opposite that MA is above or below HMA. can you add input parameter for that?
TY!

rsistoch wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 2:03 pm i tried doing that but when HMA is green (up) and SMA 1 above HMA then DB will give Flat signal, because FNC HMA logic is HMA is above or below MA. i need the opposite that MA is above or below HMA. can you add input parameter for that?
TY!

Sorry, I replied without confirming. The method "HMA is above/below MA" has been divided into "HMA faster" and "MA faster".

iardavan wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 11:35 am Reasons for Preferring FNC_XARD_Signals
I prefer FNC_XARD_Signals because it offers greater flexibility in selecting signal conditions without restrictions. In contrast, with FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, you are limited to choosing only one Entry/Exit condition (e.g., Trendline Flat, Trendline Opposite, Arrow-Trendline, etc.). The True/False selection options in FNC_XARD_Signals allow me to customize the settings precisely to my needs.
Specific Requirements
My focus is solely on the Dots, specifically:

The 4th Pink Dot with a period of 36.
After an Arrow 144, breaking to the 2nd Dot or 4th Dot, as indicated in the referenced image.
I want to exclude Trendlines or other elements entirely, keeping my strategy centered only on the Dots.

Requested Enhancements for FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals
To make FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals more suitable for my needs, I’d like the following features to be incorporated:

-Input Conditions: Add the flexible input conditions from FNC_XARD_Signals, allowing for True/False selections to customize signal conditions.
-Signal Display Options: Include the ability to select and display Flat/Up/Down(short/Long/Exit) signals.

-Sound Alarms: Integrate pre-set sound alarms from the Sounds folder to accompany the signals.
-Histogram Comment: Retain the Histogram Comment feature from version 1.00 of FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, which displays the trading symbol and timeframe. I find this feature highly practical and valuable.

Final Notes
I hope my explanations, along with the images I’ve sent (both now and previously), clearly convey my requirements. I apologize for the lengthy message and appreciate your patience.
As always, I am deeply grateful for your kindness and support toward me and all members of this community.

The following have been implemented:
An option to hide Flat signals.
The ability to set a custom sound alert by selecting a sound file from the "Sounds" folder.
The Histogram Comment feature.

Please let me know if there are any other areas that have not yet been addressed.

funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 3:37 pm Sorry, I replied without confirming. The method "HMA is above/below MA" has been divided into "HMA faster" and "MA faster".

There is one more problem, I receive notification 1 candle later when there is a valid signal. I am testing the strategy on the M5 time frame combined with the roadmap as H1, the indicators on H1 I set the parameter Bar to check is 0. I don't know if this is the reason why DB sends signal notification late or not? Can you check it.
For example to be more specific: signal is valid when M5 candle closes at 4:05, but DB will send signal notification to me at 4:10 now signal on M5 is no longer valid. This situation happens when I use DB ver 5.1, everything works fine on 5.0. I have been using FNC DB for a long time so I think all my input settings are correct.
the signal on DB still shows on right time only the notification is delayed. I tried setting delay in DB to 0 and 1 but nothing changed.

rsistoch wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 4:32 pm There is one more problem, I receive notification 1 candle later when there is a valid signal. I am testing the strategy on the M5 time frame combined with the roadmap as H1, the indicators on H1 I set the parameter Bar to check is 0. I don't know if this is the reason why DB sends signal notification late or not? Can you check it.
For example to be more specific: signal is valid when M5 candle closes at 4:05, but DB will send signal notification to me at 4:10 now signal on M5 is no longer valid. This situation happens when I use DB ver 5.1, everything works fine on 5.0. I have been using FNC DB for a long time so I think all my input settings are correct.
the signal on DB still shows on right time only the notification is delayed. I tried setting delay in DB to 0 and 1 but nothing changed.

Please post either a screenshot of the dashboard at that moment, your parameter settings, or the template.

funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 4:03 pm The following have been implemented:
An option to hide Flat signals.
The ability to set a custom sound alert by selecting a sound file from the "Sounds" folder.
The Histogram Comment feature.

Please let me know if there are any other areas that have not yet been addressed.

Thank you. I’ll test it with different conditions and time frames and share the results. Everything looks great.

«思いやり»

funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 9:30 pm Please post either a screenshot of the dashboard at that moment, your parameter settings, or the template.

Sure, pls check.
Semafor 12 Bar to check: 2
Signal box M5 bar to check: 1
all signals display on DB is correctly, only problem with alert time.
You can compare the DB time and alert time in the pictures I attached.
TY!!