If you set “Ma Period” to “1”, “Ma Applied Price” to “CLOSE”, and “Ma Method” to “SMA”, it will perform the same operation.rsistoch wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 3:26 am Hi Funchi-san, can you add option price is above or below the HMA for FNC-HMA.
TYSM!!
Reasons for Preferring FNC_XARD_Signalsfunchi wrote: Mon Aug 11, 2025 10:08 pm It appears that FNC_XARD_Signals has not had its bugs addressed as much as FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals.
Since the source code for FNC_XARD_Signals was released, no further updates have been made.
I recommend upgrading FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals rather than FNC_XARD_Signals.
It takes considerable effort to analyse source code created by someone else (in this case, my daughter).
What is the reason that FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals would not work for you?
Or, conversely, what is the reason you prefer FNC_XARD_Signals?
If necessary, I can extend FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals to include the features of FNC_XARD_Signals.
I have not yet decided how I will proceed, but once I understand the trading procedure, I intend to develop it so that it works accordingly.iardavan wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 11:35 am Reasons for Preferring FNC_XARD_Signals
I prefer FNC_XARD_Signals because it offers greater flexibility in selecting signal conditions without restrictions. In contrast, with FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, you are limited to choosing only one Entry/Exit condition (e.g., Trendline Flat, Trendline Opposite, Arrow-Trendline, etc.). The True/False selection options in FNC_XARD_Signals allow me to customize the settings precisely to my needs.
Specific Requirements
My focus is solely on the Dots, specifically:
The 4th Pink Dot with a period of 36.
After an Arrow 144, breaking to the 2nd Dot or 4th Dot, as indicated in the referenced image.
I want to exclude Trendlines or other elements entirely, keeping my strategy centered only on the Dots.
Requested Enhancements for FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals
To make FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals more suitable for my needs, I’d like the following features to be incorporated:
-Input Conditions: Add the flexible input conditions from FNC_XARD_Signals, allowing for True/False selections to customize signal conditions.
-Signal Display Options: Include the ability to select and display Flat/Up/Down(short/Long/Exit) signals.
-Sound Alarms: Integrate pre-set sound alarms from the Sounds folder to accompany the signals.
-Histogram Comment: Retain the Histogram Comment feature from version 1.00 of FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, which displays the trading symbol and timeframe. I find this feature highly practical and valuable.
Final Notes
I hope my explanations, along with the images I’ve sent (both now and previously), clearly convey my requirements. I apologize for the lengthy message and appreciate your patience.
As always, I am deeply grateful for your kindness and support toward me and all members of this community.
i tried doing that but when HMA is green (up) and SMA 1 above HMA then DB will give Flat signal, because FNC HMA logic is HMA is above or below MA. i need the opposite that MA is above or below HMA. can you add input parameter for that?funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 11:28 am If you set “Ma Period” to “1”, “Ma Applied Price” to “CLOSE”, and “Ma Method” to “SMA”, it will perform the same operation.
Sorry, I replied without confirming. The method "HMA is above/below MA" has been divided into "HMA faster" and "MA faster".rsistoch wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 2:03 pm i tried doing that but when HMA is green (up) and SMA 1 above HMA then DB will give Flat signal, because FNC HMA logic is HMA is above or below MA. i need the opposite that MA is above or below HMA. can you add input parameter for that?
TY!
The following have been implemented:iardavan wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 11:35 am Reasons for Preferring FNC_XARD_Signals
I prefer FNC_XARD_Signals because it offers greater flexibility in selecting signal conditions without restrictions. In contrast, with FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, you are limited to choosing only one Entry/Exit condition (e.g., Trendline Flat, Trendline Opposite, Arrow-Trendline, etc.). The True/False selection options in FNC_XARD_Signals allow me to customize the settings precisely to my needs.
Specific Requirements
My focus is solely on the Dots, specifically:
The 4th Pink Dot with a period of 36.
After an Arrow 144, breaking to the 2nd Dot or 4th Dot, as indicated in the referenced image.
I want to exclude Trendlines or other elements entirely, keeping my strategy centered only on the Dots.
Requested Enhancements for FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals
To make FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals more suitable for my needs, I’d like the following features to be incorporated:
-Input Conditions: Add the flexible input conditions from FNC_XARD_Signals, allowing for True/False selections to customize signal conditions.
-Signal Display Options: Include the ability to select and display Flat/Up/Down(short/Long/Exit) signals.
-Sound Alarms: Integrate pre-set sound alarms from the Sounds folder to accompany the signals.
-Histogram Comment: Retain the Histogram Comment feature from version 1.00 of FNC_XU v65m-XARD_Signals, which displays the trading symbol and timeframe. I find this feature highly practical and valuable.
Final Notes
I hope my explanations, along with the images I’ve sent (both now and previously), clearly convey my requirements. I apologize for the lengthy message and appreciate your patience.
As always, I am deeply grateful for your kindness and support toward me and all members of this community.
There is one more problem, I receive notification 1 candle later when there is a valid signal. I am testing the strategy on the M5 time frame combined with the roadmap as H1, the indicators on H1 I set the parameter Bar to check is 0. I don't know if this is the reason why DB sends signal notification late or not? Can you check it.funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 3:37 pm Sorry, I replied without confirming. The method "HMA is above/below MA" has been divided into "HMA faster" and "MA faster".
Please post either a screenshot of the dashboard at that moment, your parameter settings, or the template.rsistoch wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 4:32 pm There is one more problem, I receive notification 1 candle later when there is a valid signal. I am testing the strategy on the M5 time frame combined with the roadmap as H1, the indicators on H1 I set the parameter Bar to check is 0. I don't know if this is the reason why DB sends signal notification late or not? Can you check it.
For example to be more specific: signal is valid when M5 candle closes at 4:05, but DB will send signal notification to me at 4:10 now signal on M5 is no longer valid. This situation happens when I use DB ver 5.1, everything works fine on 5.0. I have been using FNC DB for a long time so I think all my input settings are correct.
the signal on DB still shows on right time only the notification is delayed. I tried setting delay in DB to 0 and 1 but nothing changed.
Thank you. I’ll test it with different conditions and time frames and share the results. Everything looks great.funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 4:03 pm The following have been implemented:
An option to hide Flat signals.
The ability to set a custom sound alert by selecting a sound file from the "Sounds" folder.
The Histogram Comment feature.
Please let me know if there are any other areas that have not yet been addressed.
Sure, pls check.funchi wrote: Tue Aug 12, 2025 9:30 pm Please post either a screenshot of the dashboard at that moment, your parameter settings, or the template.