Re: RSI Indicators for MT4

2541
Intrest 1 wrote: Tue Aug 08, 2023 4:54 pm Maybe I'm wrong...
If you look at thousands of overbought and oversold signals and compare the ones which failed to the ones that work, you may find that "overbought" and "oversold" is a concept that overall does not work for Forex (especially during trending markets), i. e. does not really give you an edge.
(And if you turn "overbought" and "oversold" upside down - i. e. TR in the direction of the extreme hit - it still is the same concept,)
Lots of people use it, lots of people claim it works - I just haven't seen any trustworthy statistic (with a big enough corpus) that supports the thesis...


Re: RSI Indicators for MT4

2542
josi wrote: Tue Aug 08, 2023 5:09 pm If you look at thousands of overbought and oversold signals and compare the ones which failed to the ones that work, you may find that "overbought" and "oversold" is a concept that overall does not work for Forex (especially during trending markets), i. e. does not really give you an edge.
(And if you turn "overbought" and "oversold" upside down - i. e. TR in the direction of the extreme hit - it still is the same concept,)
Lots of people use it, lots of people claim it works - I just haven't seen any trustworthy statistic (with a big enough corpus) that supports the thesis...

Rsi is related to breakout indicators in the same way as the Kelner channel. I have not seen a more accurate trend reversal indicator than the classic standard rsi. Wilder recommended using it with a period of 14 on the daily charts and it really is the best option. You won't find a better trend reversal indicator than the rsi.
These users thanked the author Intrest 1 for the post (total 2):
josi, Forexlearner

Re: RSI Indicators for MT4

2543
Intrest 1 wrote: Tue Aug 08, 2023 5:42 pm Rsi is related to breakout indicators in the same way as the Kelner channel. I have not seen a more accurate trend reversal indicator than the classic standard rsi. Wilder recommended using it with a period of 14 on the daily charts and it really is the best option. You won't find a better trend reversal indicator than the rsi.
I hear you and wish you a lot of success using it.
Your answer/claims just doesn't/don't address any of my objections.

Re: RSI Indicators for MT4

2544
Intrest 1 wrote: Tue Aug 08, 2023 4:54 pm Maybe I'm wrong, but in my opinion, rsi is made to determine the trend reversal, which signals a reversal when the price breaks the level. Therefore, rsi is a trend indicator that works on the same principle as the Keltner channel. If you want to use the breakout of the 50 level, then it is easier for you to add an SMMA of the same period to the chart,
these signals match.
The best version is the standard rsi and all kinds of modifications only worsen the signals. You can verify this by looking at various versions of the indicator.
The only exception is Connors Rsi, because it is made for completely different purposes.
Image
Very good indicator, thank you!
I don't know how it will give signals in the trend, but when it goes sideways, it's perfect. Arrows on the chart would be useful for quick scalping, ideally <3
<3 <3 <3




Who is online

Users browsing this forum: alphadimension, CrystalG, ffsss, Google Images [Bot], guppiexl, Roets1, TEAMTRADER, TransparentTrader, Yandex [Bot] and 79 guests