Cagliostro wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 6:16 pm You can use what you like, also the zigzag recalculates due to its dynamic nature, but you cannot affirm that this version does not repaint. Did you take a look at the code?

I will check later to see if there is an option to make it not repainting.

it seems you are interested in Semafor repainted and you look on solar right? I am only interested in Implementing xard's rule on his system and applying it in the way I understand you must know this market is always fluctuating in real time and no indicator is 100% winning! it depends on experience psychology how to see the market. Personally I only apply Solar and Xu-cyles for entry after the 2nd dot. entries exit according to xard rule!

xaar system is different experience i always explore it in my way and i use my system to increase my confidence with xard

vzulaks wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 6:28 pm it seems you are interested in Semafor repainted and you look on solar right? I am only interested in Implementing xard's rule on his system and applying it in the way I understand you must know this market is always fluctuating in real time and no indicator is 100% winning! it depends on experience psychology how to see the market. Personally I only apply Solar and Xu-cyles for entry after the 2nd dot. entries exit according to xard rule!

No, mate. I try to be clearer here. I am curious to learn and share with everyone, as we are here to grow together, and find fascinating your usage of the solar wind.

But, here we have a but, you said that the indicator does not repaint, I checked the code, tried to backtest it and it repaints as it uses future data to change past histo bars, period. I benchmarked dozens of bottom window indicators to confirm the zigzag arrows (exactly the same way you use solar wind for 2nd dot) and ended sticking with MACD / RSIOMA like stuff.

I have an idea how to make this solar wind not repainting, and will share it, perhaps it will be useful, perhaps not.

Wish you lot of profits!

Cagliostro wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 6:39 pm No, mate. I try to be clearer here. I am curious to learn and share with everyone, as we are here to grow together, and find fascinating your usage of the solar wind.

But, here we have a but, you said that the indicator does not repaint, I checked the code, tried to backtest it and it repaints as it uses future data to change past histo bars, period. I benchmarked dozens of bottom window indicators to confirm the zigzag arrows (exactly the same way you use solar wind for 2nd dot) and ended sticking with MACD / RSIOMA like stuff.

I have an idea how to make this solar wind not repainting, and will share it, perhaps it will be useful, perhaps not.

Wish you lot of profits!

Yes, I follow XARD's rules exactly, but to make those rules more effortless, I use a secondary window so I don't have to think much about whether the price will reverse or not. When you use someone else's system, you just improve it to make it easier to understand and use. THIS IS EXPERIENCE!

Dear Curioso,

Could you please explain more about the entry rules for the following trade?

For me, this seems like a very risky trade, so I'd appreciate more clarification:

1- DN trend is down.
2- Price is below the daily open.
3- Price is below VWAP.
4- It’s the 2nd small dot.

Please clarify these points so I can better understand

tmostafa007 wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 7:09 pm Dear Curioso,

Could you please explain more about the entry rules for the following trade?

For me, this seems like a very risky trade, so I'd appreciate more clarification:

1- DN trend is down.
2- Price is below the daily open.
3- Price is below VWAP.
4- It’s the 2nd small dot.

Please clarify these points so I can better understand

in this case you should trade at the 4th dot and the price above the trendline exits at the dot arrow. because the price can go down and the green dot arrow can redraw!

ManilaSpurs wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 3:02 pm Good morning
I really apriciate the challenge of this week from all you guys and especially from Curioso that he takes so much of his valuable time. Thanks

But now I get sometimes confused why Curioso takes a trade or not. I show you 2 examples and pls guys enlighnten me.

2024-10-23_05-45-53.png

2024-10-23_05-52-43.png

Thanks for your help.
ManilaSpurs

tmostafa007 wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 7:09 pm Dear Curioso,

Could you please explain more about the entry rules for the following trade?

For me, this seems like a very risky trade, so I'd appreciate more clarification:

1- DN trend is down.
2- Price is below the daily open.
3- Price is below VWAP.
4- It’s the 2nd small dot.

Please clarify these points so I can better understand

Hello ManilaSpurs & tmostafa007,

Thank you for your question, i put the same because the point is the same.

Remember when i say, sometimes i fell like Stuart from the Minions, that situation is the same, because i see all the trend and for is that entry, yes i know is early, but i fell the trend in that moment going up . If i recommend? No, because can be risky, unless you know are doing.
This is the way i have configure my alerts. (Enabled for current candle)

vzulaks wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 7:15 pm in this case you should trade at the 4th dot and the price above the trendline exits at the dot arrow. because the price can go down and the green dot arrow can redraw!

Hello vzulaks,

Exactly, is more secure when we are in learning process, and taking the first baby steps on this strategy.

Thank you, take this opportunity, your posts are helping a lot of members who follow us to understand us better this amazing strategy.

Combining Fibo ICT we will have the optimal entry point.

I Loosed it, just barely. The bad thing about working on 1M charts. You can't even go to the bathroom in peace. jajaj

vzulaks wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 8:21 pm Combining Fibo ICT we will have the optimal entry point.

I'm on this boat. Let's see what happens.