Jimmy wrote: Sat Sep 07, 2019 12:33 pm

Welcome to the site mate

We've moved your post into the appropriate thread. Have you had a chance to look through this topic yet?

Hi Jimmy,
Thanks for that and sorry posted int he wrong area.
Just found and looking through it now... Thank you
Beansy

Beansy wrote: Sat Sep 07, 2019 1:00 pm Hi jimmy,
Thanks for that and sorry posted int he wrong area.
Just found and looking through it now... Thank you
Beansy

No worries! Have a good weekend

Hi, Better Volume 1.5
This indicator alerts color coding is not in synch with its colors, if I am wrong please explain, THANK YOU ALL FOR THE GREAT EFFORT.

hesham keerh wrote: Thu Sep 12, 2019 10:05 am Hi, Better Volume 1.5
This indicator alerts color coding is not in synch with its colors, if I am wrong please explain, THANK YOU ALL FOR THE GREAT EFFORT.

Could you post the indicator in question please.

mrtools wrote: Fri Sep 13, 2019 2:01 am

Could you post the indicator in question please.

It is the second indicator at page 5 of this thread, sorry I don't know how to post it, please forgive me, thank you for you response.

Mod edit: Attached indicator for member

hesham keerh wrote: Fri Sep 13, 2019 9:12 am

It is the second indicator at page 5 of this thread, sorry I don't know how to post it, please forgive me, thank you for you response.

Hesham, we've attached it for you this time but in future please upload the indicator to your post using this guide: How to upload indicators or photos to your post.

This is a smoothed version of the Klinger volume oscillator with a choice of range calculation or tick volume.

hesham keerh wrote: Thu Sep 12, 2019 10:05 am Hi, Better Volume 1.5
This indicator alerts color coding is not in synch with its colors, if I am wrong please explain, THANK YOU ALL FOR THE GREAT EFFORT.

Could you test this version?

For a quick cheat sheet guide on Better Volumes colors, please see: Revised Better Volumes indicator guide (table).

mrtools wrote: Wed Sep 18, 2019 2:33 am This is a smoothed version of the Klinger volume oscillator with a choice of range calculation or tick volume.

Range calculation does not work in range mode for m1

Found still version of, but the same the problem
Would be very useful push alert

This question might be too general, but it is quite important. What is the source from the volume data? If we speak about stocks it is quite easy - it would be the actual volume traded on particulr exchange or group of exchanges (like it works in US). But what happens at Forex? Since the market is decentralized,we can assume that we see something like estimated volume calculated by the broker, which includes the impact of institutional participants and does not include the trades made by retial traders since retail brokers act as a counterpart to this trades.

Please, give a bit more light on this issue. To my mind, it is important to understand the nature of volume to be able to make decisions using it.