Re: Various (Specialist) indicators for MT4

932
mrtools wrote: Fri Jul 01, 2022 2:08 am As is per pm request, Changed out the Jma in the z score, to have an option of one of the averages in the average pack.
Image
Hi @Mr Tools and @Kvak, thanks again for the amazing work you do :D.

If I'm not going to abuse your generosity too much, is there a possibility to include the new E Averages pack within this indicator? This is one of my mains. I use it against the trend together with the JMA PPO and I'm still in the testing phase, so I'd like to see the other averages. :D

In advance, I wish you all the best, a Merry Christmas full of health, happiness, longevity and many pips/points in your pocket. hahahaha

A big hug from your Brazilian friend :D
These users thanked the author RodrigoRT7 for the post:
Chickenspicy

Re: Various (Specialist) indicators for MT4

933
RodrigoRT7 wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 12:17 am Hi @Mr Tools and @Kvak, thanks again for the amazing work you do :D.

If I'm not going to abuse your generosity too much, is there a possibility to include the new E Averages pack within this indicator? This is one of my mains. I use it against the trend together with the JMA PPO and I'm still in the testing phase, so I'd like to see the other averages. :D

In advance, I wish you all the best, a Merry Christmas full of health, happiness, longevity and many pips/points in your pocket. hahahaha

A big hug from your Brazilian friend :D
Added all the averages I have and happy holidays.
These users thanked the author mrtools for the post (total 5):
Chickenspicy, vvFish, RodrigoRT7, 太虚一毫, thomdel

Re: Various (Specialist) indicators for MT4

935
TransparentTrader wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 8:55 am To all the amazing programmers on this website, I just wanted to give this a bump and see if anybody could convert this TradingView indicator into MT4.

If everyone is too busy enjoying the holidays to tackle it, or it's too difficult to do the conversion, feel free to let me know.

Happy Holidays to everybody!




Not sure how close to the Trade view version but made this version using ema only for now
These users thanked the author mrtools for the post (total 6):
Chickenspicy, TransparentTrader, 太虚一毫, RodrigoRT7, josi, kvak


Re: Various (Specialist) indicators for MT4

936
mrtools wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 10:42 am Not sure how close to the Trade view version but made this version using ema only for now

mrtools, thank you so much for putting in the effort to replicate this indicator.

Unfortunately, it appears there's still a far distance between your MT4 version and the TradingView version.

Below is the "Buying & Selling Pressure" in MT4 and TradingView from the broker OANDA:



While the TradingView version's values barely touch 0.500 across the entire H1 timeframe, you can see in the MT4 version that the indicator goes as high as 5.00 after the sharp sell-off (10x the numerical value of the TradingView version).

This tells me that each version is running the calculation differently.

Additionally, you can see very sharp visual differences in how the indicators are plotted. Not only do the crosses happen at different points between MT4 and TradingView, but the MT4 version almost appears to be "smoothed" while the TradingView version is much more jagged in its appearance.

If it's not too much effort, would you be able to re-look at the MT4 indicator's code to see if the calculations need to be re-done? Unless my eyes are failing me, the candlestick data between MT4 and TradingView is too similar for (presumably) the same indicator to be producing drastically different plots.

Thank you again!
These users thanked the author TransparentTrader for the post:
Chickenspicy

IdeaRe: Various (Specialist) indicators for MT4

937
TransparentTrader wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 12:55 pm mrtools, thank you so much for putting in the effort to replicate this indicator.

Unfortunately, it appears there's still a far distance between your MT4 version and the TradingView version.

Below is the "Buying & Selling Pressure" in MT4 and TradingView from the broker OANDA:


Image




Image



While the TradingView version's values barely touch 0.500 across the entire H1 timeframe, you can see in the MT4 version that the indicator goes as high as 5.00 after the sharp sell-off (10x the numerical value of the TradingView version).

This tells me that each version is running the calculation differently.

Additionally, you can see very sharp visual differences in how the indicators are plotted. Not only do the crosses happen at different points between MT4 and TradingView, but the MT4 version almost appears to be "smoothed" while the TradingView version is much more jagged in its appearance.

If it's not too much effort, would you be able to re-look at the MT4 indicator's code to see if the calculations need to be re-done? Unless my eyes are failing me, the candlestick data between MT4 and TradingView is too similar for (presumably) the same indicator to be producing drastically different plots.

Thank you again!
Yeah, was way off sorry about that. Was able to make some changes think this is closer, not able to do ANY bigger changes till I get back to my regular coding computer, Sun. but was able to I think make it closer. If this code works, then will probably replace the close price with our price pack for more prices and then will add the averages besides the ema, unless someone gets to it sooner. BTW THANKS for sharing the code it looks pretty interesting.

PS: For the ongoing MT4 project of this indicator, please see here: Buy Sell Pressure indicator for MT4 (project).
These users thanked the author mrtools for the post (total 9):
太虚一毫, TransparentTrader, Chickenspicy, Jedidiah, josi, kvak, RodrigoRT7, FXchaos, Jackson Doh

Re: Various (Specialist) indicators for MT4

938
mrtools wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 2:08 pm Yeah, was way off sorry about that. Was able to make some changes think this is closer, not able to do ANY bigger changes till I get back to my regular coding computer, Sun. but was able to I think make it closer. If this code works, then will probably replace the close price with our price pack for more prices and then will add the averages besides the ema, unless someone gets to it sooner. BTW THANKS for sharing the code it looks pretty interesting.

This second version looks pretty much identical to the TradingView version, so I'd say you made the right changes!

In terms of bigger changes, I would say the ones worth making are "all averages" and "price pack" as you mentioned, along with adding MTF/AHTF capabilities.

Two much smaller changes for the future, if I ever find a valid reason for requesting them, would be (1) changing the moving average for "bpma" and "spma" separately, and (2) being able to change the length for "bpma" and "spma" separately.

Looking forward to see what you can do on Sunday or ahead of that date. No major rush as I'm on holiday like many other members here and you're probably taking time to yourself as well.

But glad to hear the code looks interesting. Always happy to find and share new and interesting things with Forex-Station that eventually end up being useful for trading.
These users thanked the author TransparentTrader for the post:
Chickenspicy

Re: Various (Specialist) indicators for MT4

940
TransparentTrader wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 2:46 pm This second version looks pretty much identical to the TradingView version, so I'd say you made the right changes!

In terms of bigger changes, I would say the ones worth making are "all averages" and "price pack" as you mentioned, along with adding MTF/AHTF capabilities.

Two much smaller changes for the future, if I ever find a valid reason for requesting them, would be (1) changing the moving average for "bpma" and "spma" separately, and (2) being able to change the length for "bpma" and "spma" separately.

Looking forward to see what you can do on Sunday or ahead of that date. No major rush as I'm on holiday like many other members here and you're probably taking time to yourself as well.

But glad to hear the code looks interesting. Always happy to find and share new and interesting things with Forex-Station that eventually end up being useful for trading.
Thanks to Mrtools shared this source and before he finishes his version, you can test this one...

PS: For the dedicated topic & ongoing MT4 project of this indicator, please see here: Buy Sell Pressure indicator for MT4 (project).
These users thanked the author kvak for the post (total 7):
Chickenspicy, TransparentTrader, RodrigoRT7, 太虚一毫, sylvester21, ParallelNative, rosalieone


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot], Bing [Bot], DotNetDotCom [Bot], IBM oBot [Bot], Majestic-12 [Bot], Narutopips, phnthnhnm, Seznam [Bot], ssscary, Telegram [Bot] and 112 guests