Display posts from previous
Sort by

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2321 by MrKelvin1
funchi wrote: Wed Jul 22, 2026 8:42 am Are you still not getting the trades to execute as expected?

I was about to check the 135.tpl file, but it is different from the one in post #2317.
Hi Mr Funchi San,

It is still not getting any trade.

This template is almost same as the 2317, just i have withdraw some FNC_DB indicator only, to test it in simple way. Sorry to confuse you.

I have noticed some difference, before that when my setting ''Allow entry if signal appeared in previous bars'' is FALSE, few weeks ago it still can trigger the trade, the trade mechanism is like this....it trigger the buy/sell order, and hit the TP/SL, it will stop for a moment before triggering the next buy/sell order...perhaps the mechanism is like... after the 1st trade, it will wait until the next retracement before it enter the trade again?

Recently it couldn't go into any trade, and the code below appears:

Code: Select all

FNC_DB_EA GBPUSD,M30 inputs: comment03=-----; OperatingAfterStartup=false; P_Enable_Entry=true; P_Enable_Exit=true; P_AllowLateEntry=false; comment01l=-----; P_Risk_Percent=0.0; P_Risk_Funds=1; P_Risk_Custom_Funds=0.0; comment01f=-----; P_Balance_Lot=0.01; P_Balance_PerLots=0.0; P_Balance_Funds=1; P_Balance_Custom_Funds=0.0; comment01=-----; P_Lot=1.2; comment02=-----; P_StopLossType=0; P_TimeFrame_SL=15; P_Price_Last_Period_SL=1; SlByPairFileName=StopLoss.txt; comment04=-----; P_TakeProfitType=51; P_TimeFrame_TP=30; TpByPairFileName=TakeProfit.txt; P_RiskReward=1.0; comment10=-----; P_TrailingStopType=0; P_TimeFrame_TS=30; P_Price_Last_Period_TS=1; TsByPairFileName=TrailingStop.txt; comment08P=----- Zero to disable -----; PercentageProfitP=0.0; ProfitAmountP=0.0; ProfitPipsP=0.0; BasketUnitP=3; BasketTPWhatIfHitP=3; comment08L=----- Zero to disable -----; PercentageProfitL=-0.0; ProfitAmountL=-0.0; ProfitPipsL=-0.0; BasketUnitL=3; BasketTPWhatIfHitL=3; comment07=----- Local PC time -----; comment07a=8:00-12:00,22:00-02:00
Will this be the problem?

Now, unless I set the ''Allow entry if signal appeared in previous bars'' to TRUE, it will trigger the trade, however the trade mechanism is different, for example, when the SEMAFOR is uptrend and the HMA is uptrend, it will trigger the 1st trade, and hit the T/P. After few seconds or a minute, it will fire a BUY trade again, until it reach to the top/peak of the trend. The only risk is saw is, when the trend it almost going to end, it trigger buy at the TOP, but the price reverse.

Thank you and sorry

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2322 by funchi
MrKelvin1 wrote: Wed Jul 22, 2026 5:42 pm
I'm not sure why changing only the lot size and the TP would cause the EA to stop trading.

I've briefly checked the log as well, but I couldn't find anything that looks suspicious.

At the moment, I suspect the issue may be related to the signals.

Have you changed anything else? This is an important question.

For example:

Did you download and reinstall the latest version of FNC_DB?
Did you make any changes to the signal configuration of FNC_DB?

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2323 by MrKelvin1
funchi wrote: Thu Jul 23, 2026 8:33 am I'm not sure why changing only the lot size and the TP would cause the EA to stop trading.

I've briefly checked the log as well, but I couldn't find anything that looks suspicious.

At the moment, I suspect the issue may be related to the signals.

Have you changed anything else? This is an important question.

For example:

Did you download and reinstall the latest version of FNC_DB?
Did you make any changes to the signal configuration of FNC_DB?
Dear Mr Funchi San,

The FNC_DB signal configuration? The FNC_DB, I have only 3 signal, but I set row 1 and row 3 to trigger the trade.

The semafor signal, i only change the period from 576 to 144, and also HMA I changed the period from 21 to 10, and HMA cross i change the period to 21, MA method to linear weighted, and Ma Applied Pirce to Close price, and Ma Shift to 0.

I didn't download and reinstall the latest version of FNC_DB, do i need to download the latest version?

This thing happened only after the demo account expired (I use demo account to test the strategy) , it expired after 60 days normally. But that doesnt't make any sense.

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2324 by funchi
MrKelvin1 wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 3:46 am Dear Mr Funchi San,

The FNC_DB signal configuration? The FNC_DB, I have only 3 signal, but I set row 1 and row 3 to trigger the trade.

The semafor signal, i only change the period from 576 to 144, and also HMA I changed the period from 21 to 10, and HMA cross i change the period to 21, MA method to linear weighted, and Ma Applied Pirce to Close price, and Ma Shift to 0.

I didn't download and reinstall the latest version of FNC_DB, do i need to download the latest version?

This thing happened only after the demo account expired (I use demo account to test the strategy) , it expired after 60 days normally. But that doesnt't make any sense.
Any changes to the "Allow entry if signal appeared in previous bars" parameter, or any modifications to the signal logic, could provide a valuable clue in identifying the cause of the issue.

I can't remember which post it was, but I hope this post explains what I'm trying to say:
post1295579285.html#p1295579285

My suspicion is that the signal detection logic has been changed. What do you think?

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2325 by MrKelvin1
funchi wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 9:24 am Any changes to the "Allow entry if signal appeared in previous bars" parameter, or any modifications to the signal logic, could provide a valuable clue in identifying the cause of the issue.

I can't remember which post it was, but I hope this post explains what I'm trying to say:
post1295579285.html#p1295579285

My suspicion is that the signal detection logic has been changed. What do you think?
I have make another two simpler template to try and error again...lets see how...funchi san can try too...

Do you mean that now i should ''Allow entry if signal appeared in previous bars" so that we can check the journal and expert tab for error? I believe is the signal detection logic too, i also suspected that....

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2326 by funchi
MrKelvin1 wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 11:49 am I have make another two simpler template to try and error again...lets see how...funchi san can try too...

Do you mean that now i should ''Allow entry if signal appeared in previous bars" so that we can check the journal and expert tab for error? I believe is the signal detection logic too, i also suspected that....
I believe the proper approach is to update all of the indicators so that they can indicate when the signal has just changed.

"Allow entry if signal appeared in previous bars" is only a temporary workaround until then.

Once the trading strategy has been finalised, I'll update the indicators that haven't yet been modified.

However, since you've said that the signal detection logic hasn't been changed, I'm unable to determine the root cause of the issue.
These users thanked the author funchi for the post:
MrKelvin1

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2328 by funchi
emrah wrote: Wed Aug 05, 2026 2:02 am Hello, could someone please explain to me why the VWAP indicator is red but appears blue on the DB chart?
Could this be due to a version difference? If so, could you please share the DB indicator for VWAP3?
When using the "FNC_VWAP" signal indicator, the only available evaluation method is "Price is above/below VWAP".
Please also note that the "FNC_VWAP" signal indicator uses the "XU v78-VWAP" indicator.
These users thanked the author funchi for the post:
emrah

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2329 by MrKelvin1
Dear Funchi San,

Its a good weekend here, and I just want to try backtesting the strategy using the MT4 strategy tester.

Is it possible to test the FNC_DB dashboard indicator together with the FNC_DB-EA expert adviser?

I understand that we can test it with demo account when market is open, but is it okay to test it using expert adviser for more confirmation and results?

My purpose is to test each dashboard strategy and backtest the result with old data.

Sorry and thank you!

Thank you.
These users thanked the author MrKelvin1 for the post:
funchi

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2330 by funchi
MrKelvin1 wrote: Sun Aug 16, 2026 5:44 am Dear Funchi San,

Its a good weekend here, and I just want to try backtesting the strategy using the MT4 strategy tester.

Is it possible to test the FNC_DB dashboard indicator together with the FNC_DB-EA expert adviser?

I understand that we can test it with demo account when market is open, but is it okay to test it using expert adviser for more confirmation and results?

My purpose is to test each dashboard strategy and backtest the result with old data.

Sorry and thank you!

Thank you.
It is not possible to backtest using the MT4 Strategy Tester.

I have considered expanding the functionality to support this in the past, but the idea was put on hold due to issues with execution speed.

At the moment, I have no plans to add this functionality.
Post Reply Attachments 1341

Return to “MT4 Trading Systems”