Display posts from previous
Sort by

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2051 by HalloweenJack
funchi wrote: Wed Sep 03, 2025 8:26 am > For the blue square area, just wondering why it didn't take any sell trade when everything seems to aligned?

The signals are not aligned on my broker’s historical data.
It seems you haven’t done any backtesting.
I also recall asking you to post your backtest results.
Thank you for all the incredible work you've done on this amazing tool.

I have a question that might be obvious, or perhaps I'm just missing something...

I'm using the Gann Made Easy strategy with the 1HR timeframe as the trend filter and the 15M timeframe as the entry trigger. What I'm trying to achieve is to only trigger an order when a new 15M signal appears that aligns with the current 1HR direction.

Here’s the issue I’m running into:

Sometimes, the 15M gives a new bullish signal while the 1HR is still bearish. Later, when the 1HR flips to bullish, it seems to trigger an order — but by then, the entry feels late, since the 15M signal is no longer fresh.

What I want is for the system to only enter on a new 15M signal that matches the current 1HR trend direction at the time the 15M signal is generated — not after the fact.

Hope that makes sense! Let me know if I’m missing something or if this behavior can be configured.

Thanks again!
These users thanked the author HalloweenJack for the post:
funchi

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2052 by newbietrader1
funchi wrote: Wed Sep 03, 2025 8:26 am > For the blue square area, just wondering why it didn't take any sell trade when everything seems to aligned?

The signals are not aligned on my broker’s historical data.
It seems you haven’t done any backtesting.
I also recall asking you to post your backtest results.
Dear Mr Funchi,

I have attached with the backtesting result, is this correct?

I have figured out and understand the Zee_SupRes and how it repaints.

Also for kingfisher too.

However, the chart kingfisher and the backtest result kingfisher, they don't appear to be the same right?

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2053 by funchi
HalloweenJack wrote: Thu Sep 04, 2025 4:35 am Thank you for all the incredible work you've done on this amazing tool.

I have a question that might be obvious, or perhaps I'm just missing something...

I'm using the Gann Made Easy strategy with the 1HR timeframe as the trend filter and the 15M timeframe as the entry trigger. What I'm trying to achieve is to only trigger an order when a new 15M signal appears that aligns with the current 1HR direction.

Here’s the issue I’m running into:

Sometimes, the 15M gives a new bullish signal while the 1HR is still bearish. Later, when the 1HR flips to bullish, it seems to trigger an order — but by then, the entry feels late, since the 15M signal is no longer fresh.

What I want is for the system to only enter on a new 15M signal that matches the current 1HR trend direction at the time the 15M signal is generated — not after the fact.

Hope that makes sense! Let me know if I’m missing something or if this behavior can be configured.

Thanks again!
At present, such a setting is not available. I’ve also thought it would be great to have, but implementing it in a general and flexible way would make the configuration quite complex, so I had put it off. I’ll now start looking into it more seriously. I can’t say for certain whether it can be done, but please bear with me in the meantime. Thank you for the excellent suggestion.
These users thanked the author funchi for the post:
HalloweenJack

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2056 by rsistoch
funchi wrote: Sun Sep 07, 2025 7:00 am Could you tell me the conditions for displaying a signal?
Yes sorry for missing information.
By the way this is an indicator in the same system used on M15. At first I thought it was a Step Average like M5 but it is not. Using 2 timeframe confirmation + H4 trend to enter trade on M5 helps increase WR and confidence. I had 6 trades with 100% WR in the past week with this system.

Signal conditions for both indicators
Buy: when price is above line and Green Line
Sell: price is below red line.

There are some sub-indicators in the window below that are still under testing, especially Sync Trend Scanner M15 looks very promising.
Here is the link for anyone who wants to test the system: post1295571731.html#p1295571731

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2057 by funchi
FNC_DB Version 5.09 – Update Announcement

We have added a new feature to consider signals in the actual order they appear and relate them to each other. This helps to align entries with market momentum more accurately.

How it works:

If an upward signal appears first on a higher timeframe, followed by an upward signal on a lower timeframe, this combination can trigger an entry.
Example: Confirm the trend on a higher timeframe, then enter on a pullback on the lower timeframe.

If multiple indicators generate upward signals at the same time, this can also trigger an entry.
Example: Multiple indicators confirm the same direction simultaneously, signalling strong momentum.

False signal prevention:

If an upward signal originates from a lower timeframe and spreads to a higher timeframe, it will not trigger an entry. This prevents entering at potential highs.

Default setting:

This feature is off by default. Use it according to your trading strategy.

Implementation note:

We will only implement this feature for FNC_ indicators for which it has been specifically requested. Indicators that do not support this feature will still work, but the new signal order colours will not appear. All other functionality remains unchanged.

Setup instructions:

Detailed instructions for using this feature will be posted in the next update.
These users thanked the author funchi for the post (total 3):
iardavan, newbietrader1, Reverent

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2058 by rsistoch
funchi wrote: Sun Sep 07, 2025 11:59 am FNC_DB Version 5.09 – Update Announcement

We have added a new feature to consider signals in the actual order they appear and relate them to each other. This helps to align entries with market momentum more accurately.

How it works:

If an upward signal appears first on a higher timeframe, followed by an upward signal on a lower timeframe, this combination can trigger an entry.
Example: Confirm the trend on a higher timeframe, then enter on a pullback on the lower timeframe.

If multiple indicators generate upward signals at the same time, this can also trigger an entry.
Example: Multiple indicators confirm the same direction simultaneously, signalling strong momentum.

False signal prevention:

If an upward signal originates from a lower timeframe and spreads to a higher timeframe, it will not trigger an entry. This prevents entering at potential highs.

Default setting:

This feature is off by default. Use it according to your trading strategy.

Implementation note:

We will only implement this feature for FNC_ indicators for which it has been specifically requested. Indicators that do not support this feature will still work, but the new signal order colours will not appear. All other functionality remains unchanged.

Setup instructions:

Detailed instructions for using this feature will be posted in the next update.
Would it be more convenient to add this feature to FNC Signal Box? There would be no need to modify each indicator to get this feature.
Please ignore if my idea is wrong.
These users thanked the author rsistoch for the post:
funchi

Re: The FNC Greedy System

2059 by funchi
New Feature: Signal Order Relation Check

In FNC_DB Version 5.09, you can now trigger entry signals by considering the actual order in which signals appear across columns.

Parameter Setup Guide:

Entry Signal Order Rule (P_SignalOrderRule)

This parameter specifies the rules as a string. Example: "1>>2,2=>3,4==5"
Symbol meanings (rule content):
== : Signals in the specified columns appear simultaneously
>> : The signal in the left column appears before the signal in the right column
=> : The signal in the left column appears before or at the same time as the right column signal
Up to 10 patterns can be set
Applicable columns: 1st to 10th

Example Usage (Rule example)

"1>>2,2=>3,4==5"
Signal in column 1 appears before column 2
Signal in column 2 appears before or simultaneously with column 3
Signals in columns 4 and 5 appear simultaneously
These users thanked the author funchi for the post (total 3):
rsistoch, iardavan, Reverent

IdeaRe: The FNC Greedy System

2060 by rsistoch
funchi wrote: Sun Sep 07, 2025 12:19 pm New Feature: Signal Order Relation Check

In FNC_DB Version 5.09, you can now trigger entry signals by considering the actual order in which signals appear across columns.

Parameter Setup Guide:

Entry Signal Order Rule (P_SignalOrderRule)

This parameter specifies the rules as a string. Example: "1>>2,2=>3,4==5"
Symbol meanings (rule content):
== : Signals in the specified columns appear simultaneously
>> : The signal in the left column appears before the signal in the right column
=> : The signal in the left column appears before or at the same time as the right column signal
Up to 10 patterns can be set
Applicable columns: 1st to 10th

Example Usage (Rule example)

"1>>2,2=>3,4==5"
Signal in column 1 appears before column 2
Signal in column 2 appears before or simultaneously with column 3
Signals in columns 4 and 5 appear simultaneously
Smart idea :thumbup:
These users thanked the author rsistoch for the post:
funchi

Post Reply Attachments 1195

Return to “MT4 Trading Systems”