nomojofomo wrote: Wed Mar 12, 2025 2:29 pm A TDI indicator that uses other oscillators

This has probably been done before, but worth sharing. I've put CCI, MFI, WPR as well as RSI as options, and then you can see how well they work.

eg the CCI doesn't have 100 as a limit, it can soar to 200-300 levels, does this offer an advantage in any way? Or the use of larger or smaller periods, like with Woodies cci?

Attached with the indicator is a pdf file about the base indicators (RSI CCI MFI WPR) and how they might be advantageous or not.

Please note how the 'levels' are different and you need to type these in yourself to suit the oscillator. eg, midline is -50 for WPR.

You are a maker of some unique most interesting TDI's and RSI's man.......... truly good and never once crossed my mind to substitute the TDI RSI for CCI or WPR.......... please stick around

nomojofomo wrote: Wed Mar 12, 2025 1:28 pm I'm doing this to show the indicator at work. Which is the tdi indicator histogram. Not the tma and whatever people think it does.

I was replying to you about TMA and what you said......"and again and again, it seems that when the ma enters into the shoulder area, price then does act stronger afterwards.... not sure why."
And asked just 1 live picture of this when it happens. Still waiting.

ROI wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 9:22 am I was replying to you about TMA and what you said......"and again and again, it seems that when the ma enters into the shoulder area, price then does act stronger afterwards.... not sure why."
And asked just 1 live picture of this when it happens. Still waiting.

I thought I had done that already but is this what you mean?

nomojofomo wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 11:06 am I thought I had done that already but is this what you mean?

UC6.png

no, ema is not in shoulder area now...or am I missing something?

ROI wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 11:50 am no, ema is not in shoulder area now...or am I missing something?

After some thinking I realise I've been missing the point of this discussion, completely.
doolfrews has already kindly and decently mentioned the error of my ways when he posted this message
"I'm sorry but these setups with repainting TMA are invalid, its an unnecessary waste of time and "hoping game" which leads nowhere. They look good only on history. I would replace the TMA with: Hurst cycles, BB with custom settings, Keltner or Vidia bands. When you play with the settings it workds well. All of them available on this great forum."

And you'll see I did reply to doolfrews, with a pragmatic answer that it's ok for the shoulder to be the way it is, continually repainting... it's the exit from the shoulder that's the trade play,(along with other things of course).

What I didn't realise is you wanted me to concede. A different game. By asking me to look for a pattern that doesn't exist because the channel had moved in relation to the moving average because price moved onwards shifting the channel. I understand. To some people showing what I showed with those areas of interest in the tma was a 'no go' because it isn't possible to act on. But that's only if you rely on the method I showed. The strong price movements that were also displayed weren't repainting though. So it's still worth considering how to access them despite the tma changing.

Have you tried the new TDI indicator with the other oscillators built in for calculations? See if you can come up with a setup that offers some very useful information.
I have found a good combo - a real "Prepared to be Paid" format. But I'll only publish it if you come up with something viable first.

A really insightful video on Youtube



Well worth a look if you are interested in using the tdi as a trading tool. Lots of trade examples from charts.

I had a scan of other videos on youtube, many are not really from a 'trader's' perspective, more a textbook style project with pretty colours with added husky voice for effects and clearly by people who don't use the tdi.

nomojofomo wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 8:29 pm By asking me to look for a pattern that doesn't exist because the channel had moved in relation to the moving average because price moved onwards shifting the channel.

And you said that this happens again and again. I spent 6 hours to see if this happens. But I don`t think you meant to lie, just wanted to be a forum hero for 15 minutes.
No harm done, happy trading.

nomojofomo wrote: Wed Mar 12, 2025 1:43 pm Thank you for the indicator, I'll check it out and if it works well together with the tdi I'll share it as a trading suggestion.

To reply to you, I don't see any problems with what I showed earlier, as the trade entry happens AFTER the shoulder is formed and price moves beyond the 13ema. So there is no repainting or reshaping of the shoulder by that time. It's over. Below is a real time example so you can see what I mean.

CC12.png

CC13.png

We don't understand each other. What I'm trying to say is that TMA repaints and the setup you are showing only works on history. E.g. its 1:00 PM you don't see the setup live but at 1:30 PM you can see the setup because TMA adjusted itself.

Edit: I missed you previous message. This is all explained then.

hi everyone, i am looking for an indicator that shows buy signal when RSI is above MBL and signal line, RSI above MBL but below signal will be neutral. since my screen is small i want it to show as histo bar like the image below. Thanks.

rsistoch wrote: Mon Mar 17, 2025 1:28 am hi everyone, i am looking for an indicator that shows buy signal when RSI is above MBL and signal line, RSI above MBL but below signal will be neutral. since my screen is small i want it to show as histo bar like the image below. Thanks.

Hello, are you looking for a histogram version separate from the TDI?