funchi wrote: Sat Jun 01, 2024 1:50 pm Supplementary explanation as there seems to be a misunderstanding. (I hope I translated it well.)


When you add the XARD indicator to a chart, it behaves as you all know it normally does. (Let's say “A”).


The tool reads the value of the XARD indicator, but does not read the value of the XARD indicator (A) added to the chart.
When reading the XARD indicator value, the tool sets a separate parameter to read the value. (Let's say “B”)

Therefore,
XARD Indicator (A) and XARD Indicator (B) are not related.
XARD Indicator (A) and XARD Indicator (B) are two different things.


Hence,
if you want to see the same results with this tool as with the XARD Indicator (A), you need to change the parameters for reading the XARD Indicator (B) values from this tool.
It is one of the problems in my opinion.

Note,
The color setting does not affect the results.
The Semafor period, MA period, etc. will affect the results.

Neroloft wrote: Sun Jun 02, 2024 1:42 am Nice updates guys, but as much as I appreciate those updates, I cant use them on my PCs. It lags my unit for some reasons. With this issue, I try to find some ways to still use xard principle to work On my cp.

Heres my cellphone setup and results last two days

Paddygir wrote: Sun Jun 02, 2024 1:55 am Your results are magnificent.
What time unit are you trading on?
Could you tell me your indicator parameters RSI and (2x MA) and CCI.

Thanks and congratulations

Patrick

Mork01 wrote: Sun Jun 02, 2024 12:22 am Hi funchi,
for better understanding:
what is the impact of not to have same value in the tool and in the displayed chart ?
Can this issue be workarounded and this needs to be done for each XARD version as you did for V010 or it is unknown how to solve the issue ?
Thank you.
Mork01
P.S. I remixed funchi's for-the-lazies-like-me-tool with funchi's V010 template. Attached.

funchi wrote: Sun Jun 02, 2024 6:12 am XARD is a system.
The template I created just displays each indicator as is.

In particular, the arrows on XARD's Semafor do not seem to be displayed as is.
Unless you know how this works, you will not get the same results.

> Can this issue be workarounded and this needs to be done for each XARD version as you did for V010 or it is unknown how to solve the issue ?
Must be created for each XARD version.

funchi wrote: Sat Jun 01, 2024 2:00 pm I am now wondering which of two ways to release it.

1. continue with the current version and add functionality? (Version that references XARD indicator values)

　　Advantages
　　　　Works faithfully to XARD signals.

　　Disadvantages
　　　　Requires tools for each version.
　　　　Parameters of the XARD indicator cannot be changed. Limited number of parameters that can be changed.

2. Should versatility be prioritized? (Versions that do not reference XARD indicator values)

　　Advantages
　　　　May be compatible with each version of XARD.
　　　　Possible to change parameters.

　　Disadvantages
　　　　Does not work faithfully with XARD signals.
　　　　XARD's Semafor arrows seem to be different from regular Semafor arrows.


It would be helpful to hear your opinions.

Curioso wrote: Sun Jun 02, 2024 9:38 am Hello funchi,

First of all I would like to congratulate you on your excellent work, I totally agree with you and your vision is very good, but I believe that some modules are missing if possible to implement that will help many traders.

For example, I have opened 4 different TFs with all the original settings and without changing anything, but i didn´t receive any alerts, and at the moment we have the conditions an alert or notification would be very interesting, and so for the moments when we are not in front of the computer it would be important to receive them and take the respective actions according to our rules.

From what I've seen of your work, it's possible and I believe it will help many traders, what do you think about this topic?

funchi wrote: Sun Jun 02, 2024 10:03 am I too think alerts and notifications to mobile devices would be useful.

I'm still wondering whether to go with proposal 1 or 2.

There are many issues.
There are also technical considerations. (In the case of Proposal 1)
There are also considerations for Mr. xard777. (In the case of proposal 2)
post1295542897.html#p1295542897