kvak wrote: Sun Mar 24, 2024 9:34 pm XMA confirmation Histogram (NNFX) with MA Filters + AHTF MTF

Hello, try it, I also update code and added mtf.

Thank you for this. Very timely. Any chance you could build an MT5 version of this? I am happy to help if pressed for time.

lukgoku wrote: Wed Mar 27, 2024 10:09 pm Hi Kvak,

is there also a version with alerts?

Thank you for your effort

XMA confirmation Histogram (NNFX) with MA Filters + AHTF MTF + Alerts & Arrows

Hello.
Here is version with alerts and arrows.
Also I made some change in code to make arrows and alerts working.....
What I tested, this new version looks similar to old one., but test it and give me a feadback.

p.s. for now, there is not MT5 version.

Hi Kvak,
for my settings it's fine!

Thank you!

Indicator conversion from HERE

First version to test.
I think that's about all I can do to convert.

kvak wrote: Thu Apr 18, 2024 4:38 am Indicator conversion from HERE

First version to test.
I think that's about all I can do to convert.

Awesome job! I'll be comparing this in OANDA TradingVIew and MT4 as promised to see how similar they are. I'll reply to your original post with the results when I'm finished.

kvak wrote: Thu Apr 18, 2024 4:38 am Indicator conversion from HERE

First version to test.
I think that's about all I can do to convert.

Ok, so here are my preliminary results. I had to use FOREX.com instead of OANDA because the latter is having issues with me resetting the password for my old portal account. I used the SPX500 on the M1 timeframe.


Above is TradingView. On the highlighted candle (open 5027.7, high 5028.7, low 5025.4, close 5027.4), we get the following values:

• Top of the red bubble is 30.4
• The upper-most grey line comes in at 18.8
• The second upper-most grey line comes in at 9.4
• The red thick line comes in at 7.1
• The third upper-most grey line comes in at 4.8
• The third bottom-most grey line comes in at -4.8
• The green thick line comes in at -7.1
• The second bottom-most grey line comes in at -9.4
• The third bottom-most grey line comes in at -18.8
• Bottom of the red bubble is -30.4

Above is MetaTrader 4. On the highlighted candle (open 5020.9, high 5022.2, low 5018.9, close 5020.9), we get the following values:

• Top of the red bubble (lighter red line here) is 30.3781
• The upper-most grey line comes in at 27.9921
• The second upper-most grey line comes in at 13.9323
• The red thick line comes in at 7.9844
• The third upper-most grey line comes in at 7.4820
• The third bottom-most grey line comes in at -7.4820
• The green thick line comes in at -7.05 (actually a higher value)
• The second bottom-most grey line comes in at -13.9960
• The third bottom-most grey line comes in at -27.8645
• Bottom of the red bubble (lighter green line here) is -30.3781

Also, pay close attention to how the indicator looks visually. In TradingView we see the mid-chart spike and drop where the green/red bubbles appear above the highest grey line for far longer and far higher than the value of the grey line itself.

The same thing is not observed in MetaTrader 4. I can't tell if this is because of slightly different candle values between the two platforms that would entirely change how it appears when looking back in time.

That's where I am for now.

kvak, would it be possible to add in color filling options so the MT4 version looks exactly like the TradingView version? Appreciate all the hard work you've put so far into this indicator request.

kvak wrote: Thu Apr 18, 2024 4:38 am Indicator conversion from HERE

First version to test.
I think that's about all I can do to convert.

Thank you so much for this new creation! I fell down when I tried it!
I scalp in M1 and have never experienced anything like it. It feels like you're driving a car, you always know where you are and what to do.

thanks also to TransparentTrader for reporting the indicator!

can someone help me identify this indicator

lukgoku wrote: Fri Apr 19, 2024 2:26 am Thank you so much for this new creation! I fell down when I tried it!
I scalp in M1 and have never experienced anything like it. It feels like you're driving a car, you always know where you are and what to do.

thanks also to TransparentTrader for reporting the indicator!

Hello,
What setting you used? And you use cross of term lines cross? Or cross it with bands?

FYI @TransparentTrader Iam working on "filled" version.... but it's late here, I'm going to bed

kvak wrote: Fri Apr 19, 2024 7:00 am Hello,
What setting you used? And you use cross of term lines cross? Or cross it with bands?

FYI @TransparentTrader Iam working on "filled" version.... but it's late here, I'm going to bed

No problem, take your time!

Likewise, I'm interested in seeing how lukgoku uses the indicator and his settings.