Could somebody put message & audio alerts on EATA arrows please?

Attached, thanks

MX01 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 10:13 pm Could somebody put message & audio alerts on EATA arrows please?

Attached, thanksEATA.mq4

I found this but it is an unreliable indicator ..

MX01 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 10:13 pm Could somebody put message & audio alerts on EATA arrows please?

Attached, thanksEATA.mq4

pacois wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 10:34 pm I found this but it is an unreliable indicator ..

This is a typical Pollan indicator. They heavily repaint all the time, so arrows and alerts are useless (bothersome and fake).

Krelian99 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 10:40 pm



This is a typical Pollan indicator. They heavily repaint all the time, so arrows and alerts are useless (bothersome and fake).

I tried to correct, but I do not know the results ..

Krelian99 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 10:40 pm



This is a typical Pollan indicator. They heavily repaint all the time, so arrows and alerts are useless (bothersome and fake).

Thanks for clarifying again. Just wanted to test but if that's the case then it's pointless.

pacois wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 10:47 pm I tried to correct, but I do not know the results ..

No, it's not possible. mladen and other already looked over it at TSD times. It must repaint when you sum values of an indi with multiple periods. When candle closes and you go to next one, the whole calculation changes and let the result look pretty good - not perfect, but very good, but in reality it isn't.

MX01 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 10:47 pm Thanks for clarifying again. Just wanted to test but if that's the case then it's pointless.

Sorry, but I can't the 'discussion' about the Pollan indis anymore. Only the inventor was sure that it doesn't repaint

Krelian99 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 11:19 pm

No, it's not possible. mladen and other already looked over it at TSD times. It must repaint when you sum values of an indi with multiple periods. When candle closes and you go to next one, the whole calculation changes and let the result look pretty good - not perfect, but very good, but in reality it isn't.




Sorry, but I can't the 'discussion' about the Pollan indis anymore. Only the inventor was sure that it doesn't repaint

Pacois' version does not repaint. But not sure what settings are good for any type of expiration. Seems needs an additional indi filter to know which signals to take.

MX01 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 11:23 pm Pacois' version does not repaint. But not sure what settings are good for any type of expiration. Seems needs an additional indi filter to know which signals to take.

True, it isn't a real Pollan indi anymore and this one calculates it for every candle correct and not flowingly (don't know whether it is the right word). The drawback is that the signal now lags a lot and in sideway markets you buy often exactly the ceiling and sell the bottom. This is a good example how an indicator changes when made nrp.

Krelian99 wrote: Thu Mar 22, 2018 11:19 pm

No, it's not possible. mladen and other already looked over it at TSD times. It must repaint when you sum values of an indi with multiple periods. When candle closes and you go to next one, the whole calculation changes and let the result look pretty good - not perfect, but very good, but in reality it isn't.




Sorry, but I can't the 'discussion' about the Pollan indis anymore. Only the inventor was sure that it doesn't repaint

When it is so necessary to use this with old/usual indies,why cant a user select the best one from (Mladens-Mrtools) advanced with fantastic featured reliable CCI's,RSI's,and MA's and apply best settings individually that suits him/her and pick the open/close trade when all 3 telling same thing (open/close)

mntiwana wrote: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:55 am When it is so necessary to use this with old/usual indies,why cant a user select the best one from (Mladens-Mrtools) advanced with fantastic featured reliable CCI's,RSI's,and MA's and apply best settings individually that suits him/her and pick the open/close trade when all 3 telling same thing (open/close)

There wouldn't be no nrp-discussion at all if so. You need time to identify a good indi and compare it with repainting indis or recalculating ones for purpose. The question must always be for what is the indi (and the settings) and what story it tells you - not what you want to hear. If guys come around with OB/OS on RSI, they don't understand the indi at all (yes, Welles Wilder suggested such a thing, but in 2018 we all should know he was wrong) and how should they know what to do with the market. A good trader may not always know how the price moves next time, but he always knows what to do. Therefore, you must know why the indi moves how it moves.