Renko77 wrote: Wed Mar 12, 2025 3:29 pm Right now no. 1 topic/thread on FS.
I would like to discuss two main indicators

#PR: do you think different PR setting for different pairs? For example Gold, indices heavy movement compare to currency pairs daily movement around 50/100pips?

#Super Arrow: kindly share your deep experience with Superarrow ? In Beatles thread he used lower setting but lot of false signals , i mean too much repaint
In your previous versions and current i observed you shift lower setting to high for less repaint and more accurate signal.

Do you think if you go more higher setting then repaint issue is totally solved? Or add or remove some indicator from super arrow?

Sorry for bad English, maybe my approach is wrong but i would like to solve the super arrow mystery and need long positive discussion.
Thanks

The Len parameter in the PR indicator defines the range of K-lines involved in the calculation. A larger value indicates evaluating volatility over a longer period, which can effectively filter out market noise but inevitably sacrifices some short-term profitable opportunities. However, this trade-off is generally considered worthwhile, isn’t it?

Renko77 wrote: Wed Mar 12, 2025 3:29 pm Right now no. 1 topic/thread on FS.
I would like to discuss two main indicators

#PR: do you think different PR setting for different pairs? For example Gold, indices heavy movement compare to currency pairs daily movement around 50/100pips?

#Super Arrow: kindly share your deep experience with Superarrow ? In Beatles thread he used lower setting but lot of false signals , i mean too much repaint
In your previous versions and current i observed you shift lower setting to high for less repaint and more accurate signal.

Do you think if you go more higher setting then repaint issue is totally solved? Or add or remove some indicator from super arrow?

Sorry for bad English, maybe my approach is wrong but i would like to solve the super arrow mystery and need long positive discussion.
Thanks

Okay, I will talk about the PR settings:

With the old parameters on version V9 and V10, calculating the total volume across an MTF required a large amount of resources and slowed down the system. After improving this issue to reduce memory consumption, I ensured that the calculations still followed the old method while maintaining the default volume levels. However, the data accuracy for currencies has been significantly improved.

That said, for gold and BTC, due to their constantly fluctuating volumes, the accuracy is not as high as with currencies. Therefore, I recommend choosing an asset where PR works effectively—you will make more money than if you focus on gold and BTC.

As a result, the settings are now more flexible. You can adjust LEN = 89 instead of 121, or even shorter if you want to scalp.
Issues with the Super Arrow Indicator:
It repaints on lower timeframes, and since I don’t have its source code, setting it to follow trends on higher timeframes (above H1) is a more reliable choice. However, in some cases, it doesn’t repaint because it is based on the following indicators: Moving Averages, Relative Strength Index, Bollinger Bands, and Magic Filter.

Because of this, sometimes it will repaint, and sometimes it won’t. I cannot modify it, but I can use higher timeframes to confirm the trend. If you find it difficult or uncertain, try using the ATS trend from ATS v6, which does not repaint. Personally, I like it too.

In version V12x, I used XARD’s semafor to determine trends, but instead of following XARD’s second-dot rule, use my 3-in-1 rule instead. This means that after a dot appears, the Jurik + Xu 3MA + Kingfisher’s color combination should align.

Good luck!

LIKE wrote: Wed Mar 12, 2025 4:47 pm The Len parameter in the PR indicator defines the range of K-lines involved in the calculation. A larger value indicates evaluating volatility over a longer period, which can effectively filter out market noise but inevitably sacrifices some short-term profitable opportunities. However, this trade-off is generally considered worthwhile, isn’t it?

In reality, I use **PR for swing trading on H1**, and it works best with the **PR fix version**.

Gold and BTC may not be fully optimized when PR signals appear during reversals. However, instead of scalping on **M5**, it is more **optimized on H1**. This way, you can achieve your **target profit more effectively**.

vzulaks wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 2:21 am In reality, I use **PR for swing trading on H1**, and it works best with the **PR fix version**.

Gold and BTC may not be fully optimized when PR signals appear during reversals. However, instead of scalping on **M5**, it is more **optimized on H1**. This way, you can achieve your **target profit more effectively**.

Im currently using the PR fix version on the H4 for day trading and also on the m15 and it works great. currently building up my account from 10$.

vzulaks wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 2:21 am In reality, I use **PR for swing trading on H1**, and it works best with the **PR fix version**.

Gold and BTC may not be fully optimized when PR signals appear during reversals. However, instead of scalping on **M5**, it is more **optimized on H1**. This way, you can achieve your **target profit more effectively**.

i also use PR on H1 look so great for forex pair. I'm using len 89.
I see that the win rate seems very high but the signals are quite few. Usually there is 1 signal per week.
Is there any setting for more PR signals?
I see that PR often appears when the current trend reverses to form a new trend.
In the new trend, there will be several pullbacks.
If VZU improves PR to detect when the pullback has ended and the current trend continues, it will be great.
I am trading H1 without caring about the trend in the higher time frame.
Thank VZU, you are so generous to share this great indicator.
Sr for my english

Hi VZU, i have an idea, can you create an EA that closes the trade when the opposite PR appears?
for example i have a buy order and whenever a sell PR appears the EA will close the order automatically.
It will work very well on H1.
EA Just close the order automatically, whether to open the trade or not is still up to the human decision.
Observing the chart every time a new H1 candle appears will affect our health a lot even though it only takes about 1-2 minutes each time.
We all need good sleep at night.
Thank you VZU!!!

rsistoch wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 9:09 am Hi VZU, i have an idea, can you create an EA that closes the trade when the opposite PR appears?
for example i have a buy order and whenever a sell PR appears the EA will close the order automatically.
It will work very well on H1.
EA Just close the order automatically, whether to open the trade or not is still up to the human decision.
Observing the chart every time a new H1 candle appears will affect our health a lot even though it only takes about 1-2 minutes each time.
We all need good sleep at night.
Thank you VZU!!!

That’s good idea but i dont write code EA.

i only trade on H1

PR signal rule H1+3 in 1

with code xauusd Week only appears 1 or 2 times with R:R ratio. 1: 2.5 -3. Too great

i will learn how to trade on other currency pairs and share here

nguyenlun25118 wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 6:52 pm i only trade on H1
i will learn how to trade on other currency pairs and share here

Don't you look at the trends of higher timeframes at all? I mean liquidity too.
Thank you

Hi VZU, can you make mail alert and mobile alert on PR?
Thank you.