Uploaded the latest version.
Please download from post #1.
Version 23.064
viewtopic.php?p=1295507591#p1295507591

<Indicator added>
- MACD divergence signal (FNC_dashboard_Ind_ms_MACD_Divergence)
- RSI divergence signal (FNC_dashboard_Ind_ms_RSI_Divergence)

i know there is a language barrier with funchi, and what I'm saying can be confusing, but i would still like to discussing something about the Semaphore and 2nd dot, and i would like your opinion on something. I think it's broken as it is

In this pic there is the Big white Semaphore at the end showing up, and it obviously shows on the dashboard. But it is still clearly a down trend. The 2nd dot also doesn't appear because of it. This happens a lot.

It's calculating everything right, but from a dashboard perspective it breaks the system.

This type of semaphore should not appear at the end, until there is a 2nd dot to confirm it. The dashboard should ignore it until it is followed by a 2nd dot. That way the system would make sense by the XARD system

I don't know how this could be coded. Anyway what do you guys think?

funchi wrote: Thu Jun 08, 2023 1:32 pm Uploaded the latest version.
Please download from post #1.
Version 23.064
viewtopic.php?p=1295507591#p1295507591

<Indicator added>
- MACD divergence signal (FNC_dashboard_Ind_ms_MACD_Divergence)
- RSI divergence signal (FNC_dashboard_Ind_ms_RSI_Divergence)

hello funchi
I use the latest version of fnc with the template 20 the EA version and I noticed that it takes almost no trades anymore, when I use old versions there are a lot more trades in your opinion why?

Forexlearner wrote: Sat Jun 10, 2023 12:04 am i know there is a language barrier with funchi, and what I'm saying can be confusing, but i would still like to discussing something about the Semaphore and 2nd dot, and i would like your opinion on something. I think it's broken as it is

In this pic there is the Big white Semaphore at the end showing up, and it obviously shows on the dashboard. But it is still clearly a down trend. The 2nd dot also doesn't appear because of it. This happens a lot.

It's calculating everything right, but from a dashboard perspective it breaks the system.

This type of semaphore should not appear at the end, until there is a 2nd dot to confirm it. The dashboard should ignore it until it is followed by a 2nd dot. That way the system would make sense by the XARD system

I don't know how this could be coded. Anyway what do you guys think?

This is my understanding of the XARD system, please point out if I am wrong.
As for the outline,
Don't be greedy.
Trade trend following from large semaphore to large semaphore.
Trade within that trend.

In other words, enter from 2nd,
ADR 61.8, or the color of the candle, or the large semaphore, etc,
Exit at a time when you are not greedy.


Assuming you changed the display of the large semaphore as you posted,
There may be some objections.

For example,
Suppose the 2nd semaphore is not displayed and the opposite large semaphore is displayed as it is.
Then,
If the larger semaphore is displayed, but the signal is not displayed on the dashboard, there will be a problem.


The question is,
Is there a relationship between the time axis setting, the semaphore setting, and the size of the trend?
I think changing the semaphore and time axis settings will solve the problem.

Or, the strategy and dashboard settings do not match.


By the way,
Don't display the larger semaphore until the 2nd is displayed,
I will first try to create an improved version of the indicator (FNC_Semafor).

dio889 wrote: Sat Jun 10, 2023 8:25 am hello funchi
I use the latest version of fnc with the template 20 the EA version and I noticed that it takes almost no trades anymore, when I use old versions there are a lot more trades in your opinion why?

I forget the version,
There was an inadequacy in the display of signals, which resulted in more trades.
It was a good flaw depending on market conditions,
But it was a flaw that was not in accordance with the XARD system.

Is it not?

If it is #20, I have posted the number of transactions per week for your reference.
Weeks with a high number of trades are weeks in which there was a signal failure.

viewtopic.php?p=1295513041#p1295513041

Forexlearner wrote: Sat Jun 10, 2023 12:04 am
This type of semaphore should not appear at the end, until there is a 2nd dot to confirm it. The dashboard should ignore it until it is followed by a 2nd dot. That way the system would make sense by the XARD system

I don't know how this could be coded. Anyway what do you guys think?

Upper side is as before.
The bottom is a version that does not display the large semaphore until the 2nd semaphore is displayed.

The 2nd remains undisplayed,
When the next larger semaphore is displayed, The previous large semaphore is displayed.
Valid only for the last large semaphore.

The parameter "DisplayLargeWhen2ndDisplayed" is used to set this.

Please check the indicator first.

funchi wrote: Sat Jun 10, 2023 8:46 am I forget the version,
There was an inadequacy in the display of signals, which resulted in more trades.
It was a good flaw depending on market conditions,
But it was a flaw that was not in accordance with the XARD system.

Is it not?

If it is #20, I have posted the number of transactions per week for your reference.
Weeks with a high number of trades are weeks in which there was a signal failure.

viewtopic.php?p=1295513041#p1295513041

in fact I speak of the version of 23052023
it takes almost no trade and if I use the version of 15052023 then it works better then I don't know what happened with the version 23052023
I specify that I use the 2 versions with the same settings and the same broker and yet the version of 23052023 launches almost no trades

dio889 wrote: Sun Jun 11, 2023 3:41 am in fact I speak of the version of 23052023
it takes almost no trade and if I use the version of 15052023 then it works better then I don't know what happened with the version 23052023
I specify that I use the 2 versions with the same settings and the same broker and yet the version of 23052023 launches almost no trades

No version control.
No version history.

Can you post your achievements?
To be addressed to work correctly,
I need specific examples of defects.

I only maintain the latest version.
Improvements, feature additions, and bug fixes are always made to the latest version.
There is no compatibility between versions.
Thank you in advance for your cooperation.

funchi wrote: Sat Jun 10, 2023 9:49 am Upper side is as before.
The bottom is a version that does not display the large semaphore until the 2nd semaphore is displayed.

The 2nd remains undisplayed,
When the next larger semaphore is displayed, The previous large semaphore is displayed.
Valid only for the last large semaphore.

The parameter "DisplayLargeWhen2ndDisplayed" is used to set this.

Please check the indicator first.

I see what you're saying, you get a domino effect, changing all the semaphores back. Let me look into it.