.

Indicator requests and ideas

Moderators: mntiwana, mrtools



Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3782
mladen wrote:
Thu Aug 09, 2018 8:10 pm
Samnix wrote:
Thu Aug 09, 2018 1:29 pm


Hello mrtools,
there are indicators on the market of mql4 where an RSI or a CCI crossing a self drawn trendline in the subwindow with alert.
Is it because of the two indicators I posted, that it can`t be done?
Best Regards
That is not a good idea - such combinations are, more or less, nonsense
Wow, I am realy happy now. I thought here are the gods of the universe at home...
I am glad, just normal people which can be so, so wrong.
Well mladen, what if my buddy made with trix-tsi-cross 1200% last week on Ger30 (with proof)
Is it still "nonsense" ? I don`t think so. Come on what about your "experiments" with indicator ideas? What about thinking out of the box?
Is there no challenge left ?
Don`t get me wrong... biggest respect, no question, but after all you are just a human who can be wrong too.
Hope you can stand criticism. Regards

Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3783
Samnix wrote:
Fri Aug 10, 2018 1:13 am
mladen wrote:
Thu Aug 09, 2018 8:10 pm


That is not a good idea - such combinations are, more or less, nonsense
Wow, I am realy happy now. I thought here are the gods of the universe at home...
I am glad, just normal people which can be so, so wrong.
Well mladen, what if my buddy made with trix-tsi-cross 1200% last week on Ger30 (with proof)
Is it still "nonsense" ? I don`t think so. Come on what about your "experiments" with indicator ideas? What about thinking out of the box?
Is there no challenge left ?
Don`t get me wrong... biggest respect, no question, but after all you are just a human who can be wrong too.
Hope you can stand criticism. Regards
Hello Samnix,
You can do RSI of something or CCI of something, but there are some request that makes the coder know real quick the requester doesn't have a basic understanding of the nature of base indicators.
We have had a few concoctions made here over time and some abominations too.
For individuals with experience as Mr Mladen and Mr tools you should trust their judgment.
Also, we have quite a lot of indicators here with updated prices and pretty much all the MA methods your mind can conjure so its best to get acquainted real quick with the resources here.
Just my I cent

Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3784
Samnix wrote:
Fri Aug 10, 2018 1:13 am
Wow, I am realy happy now. I thought here are the gods of the universe at home...
I am glad, just normal people which can be so, so wrong.
Well mladen, what if my buddy made with trix-tsi-cross 1200% last week on Ger30 (with proof)
Is it still "nonsense" ? I don`t think so. Come on what about your "experiments" with indicator ideas? What about thinking out of the box?
Is there no challenge left ?
Don`t get me wrong... biggest respect, no question, but after all you are just a human who can be wrong too.
Hope you can stand criticism. Regards
So young and yet so cynical. Maybe what mladen meant is that one independent indi can't be the signal line for another. An MA can be signal line since it is calculated out of the values of the base indi, like you have in Stochs or MACDs. On the other hand how you calculate the crossing point? You have a cross when Trix = TSI. You have two indis with no boundaries. Have you scrolled your screen to the left or right? The imaginary crossing points move, they aren't fix. And they haven't the same dimension. You must normalize both and scale one in/out and then you have a Frankenstein with parts that doesn't fit together at all.

BTW, 1200% a week is a hell bad money management. All guys trading with such an super high risk hit the very ground super hard earlier or later, just a matter of time. Combined without an bulletproofed strategy his account is a hippo in a rollercoaster. If you like your money, you'll must find something more solid.

Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3785
Samnix wrote:
Thu Aug 02, 2018 10:14 am
Hello mladen, mr. tools,

hope this kind of indi is a new idea and codable.

The indicator I am thinking of is a combination of mladens trix advanced amp alerts (mtf) and mladens Blau tsi mtf 2 (new).

In the pic you see an example of settings, where tsi and trix crossing each other. For that matter it would be nice to have "Blau_tsi_trix_cross_mtf" indicator.

Message, email, push alerts, mtf, interpolated. Trix period, price settings. No Histogramm needed, no Signal period and method needed Alerts on current or close.

Only one tsi line and one trix line which are used for crossings. (tsi visible divs of course too, alerting those is a bit too much asked).

tsi trix cross.png

trix_advanced_amp_alerts.mq4

It would be great, if the new indi could be coded out of those two indicators, because they are working very good together with nice results.
Example: ger30 H1, setting tsi 50/8/8 and trix (no signal line) setting 50.

Hope you, mladen or mr tools could have a closer look at it.
Thank you very much.
___________________________________________________________________

Note : Originally indicator name should be go like this "trix advanced alerts" - (mod)
Just take TSI and MA to it. Compare that with your pic, not so far, just try different settings, after all, trix is MA.
AUDNZDM30.png

tsi trix cross.png


Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3786
Thanks guys for your opinions, experience about indis and moneymanagement.
My point was to make clear, compared to a hundred indis here, which are realy nonsense and no money is to make with, this idea has "money proof" and a long history of trying useless indis.
Ok I wouldn`t do this money rollercoaster, but it is his money...
To get a serios tech explanation, like Krelian99, why it isn`t possible to combine those two indis and getting an alert, is way more pro, than saying it`s nonsense.

Even if we are all beggars here, asking for a free foundation of wealth, it feels like disrespect getting such answers.

I understand everything here is free and all the hard work, but years of "buttkissing" from thousand people leavs marks. All human, all natural psychology.
Well I guess my buddy (and me) have to go without alerts. Just a bit more chart-time. All good.

With respect !

Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3787
Samnix wrote:
Fri Aug 10, 2018 1:13 am
mladen wrote:
Thu Aug 09, 2018 8:10 pm


That is not a good idea - such combinations are, more or less, nonsense
Wow, I am realy happy now. I thought here are the gods of the universe at home...
I am glad, just normal people which can be so, so wrong.
Well mladen, what if my buddy made with trix-tsi-cross 1200% last week on Ger30 (with proof)
Is it still "nonsense" ? I don`t think so. Come on what about your "experiments" with indicator ideas? What about thinking out of the box?
Is there no challenge left ?
Don`t get me wrong... biggest respect, no question, but after all you are just a human who can be wrong too.
Hope you can stand criticism. Regards
Don't get me wrong, but :
  • You asked a question and you got the answer - if you don't like it : I wish you all the luck if you are ruled by emotions when trading and using TA
  • The second part is what we all know as usual commercial spamming - thank you for clarifying why someone was asking nonsense question about nonsense product that is then attempted to be sold.

    The "proof" you are mentioning is usually called a coin tossing tactics : someone takes trades on 100 symbols (more or less randomly - as in your case since comparing values that are bounded in 0 to 100 range to values that are not bounded at all is pure randomness) and then shows results for only the positive trades. Then it is done the same again the next week, and again only the results for positive are shown. And so on and on and on ... Seen that for million times - don't bother showing that (at least to me, please, don't)
  • I am in this for years and years : do you really think that it is the first time that some commercial spammer have attempted to use some post of mine as a cause for flaming and as a "proof" for the nonsense that he/she was trying to paddle to people? Think again
Hope you can stand the truth ... (since I will not be answering posts of your any more)
Good bye

Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3788
mrtools wrote:
Tue Aug 07, 2018 4:01 am
mehkhan wrote:
Tue Aug 07, 2018 2:45 am
ma rsi adaptive - floating levels - on chart - 2.4.ex4 Dear mrtools, please add arrows option on color change. Regards.
Been looking don't think i have the source code of that indicator.
Oh damn :( That indi is absolutely great but its super heavy on CPU. Turning interpolate off helps slightly.

Re: Indicator requests and ideas

#3789
Gud day Mladen and Mr.tools and other traders,
the attached indicator does not show signals in real time and alerts as well.... Can you please make it work in real time with on the time alerts.
THANKS IN ADVANCED
Attachments
AFBSR breakout alert.mq4
(7.1 KiB) Downloaded 175 times


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot], alilou31, appsoluxions, CommonCrawl [Bot], farxad, FBI, fx4me, Giangyforex, Komoles, Monachus, nrv, reachme, rudiarius, Seznam [Bot], TravisS, trinitygod3, wasunji and 50 guests