Page 75 of 198

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Sun May 23, 2021 6:00 pm
by schmurex
Meyney wrote: Sat May 22, 2021 12:58 am gy 1H see this spike at round nr and SD...not very bullish agree
A confirmation of your analysis from another perspective: Supply and Demand,
1 TF above in solid colours and 2 TFs above outlined only.
D1 Supply is a bit confusing since price have been playing inside for 2 weeks

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Sun May 23, 2021 6:19 pm
by schmurex
maybe a clearer view from M15 with price reacting to H1 zones embedded inside H4 zones

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Sun May 23, 2021 6:39 pm
by schmurex
Here is a modified version of the Supply and demand indicator.
Since I believe that using 3 TF is critical I have added an auto TF feature that allow to display S&D on 1 or 2 TFs above (what I use)
I have added a 3 TFs Up option that would allow to see H1 from M1 as you do Meyney.
(M30) is discounted as too close to M15 and H1...)
Hope it works for you as I'm no coder, just learning, thanks to the great coders here who offer their works as mql4 files for everyone to study their code,
(edited indicator to get the full input line "CommentTfUp" readable with all options available)

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Mon May 24, 2021 5:39 pm
by Lesley919
Found this indicator Rox's RSI stop and reverse (viewtopic.php?p=1295434198#p1295434198) in Daily Download Thread. It helps people like me who don't master how to draw trendlines. Maybe Supertrend does the same thing but I think this is better. Just my thoughts.

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 4:23 am
by Meyney
gy 1m not easy today (bank holidays) but after all a few entries. This is how you can filter bad entries and yes you will miss a few big moves sometimes.

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Wed May 26, 2021 3:48 am
by Meyney
Today was better=easy for gy 1M. Sitting on your hands while price is taking off is difficult. SD zones will help. Problem with almost all SD indi's here is they will only plot the zones when the direction is already made=when down only SD's at the highs/when up only SD's at the lows. Try to create SD zones also for 'the other side'.

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Wed May 26, 2021 7:30 am
by schmurex
Meyney wrote: Wed May 26, 2021 3:48 am Today was better=easy for gy 1M. Sitting on your hands while price is taking off is difficult. SD zones will help. Problem with almost all SD indi's here is they will only plot the zones when the direction is already made=when down only SD's at the highs/when up only SD's at the lows. Try to create SD zones also for 'the other side'.
Hi Meyney,
I think what you're after is a Support and Resistance indicator. The zone drawn on your chart is SR (see magenta lines on my chart)
As the theory goes, the more SR lines are tested the stronger they get, Price will eventually pass through and they would flip from S to R and the opposite, but they are not negated. (if you scroll back, the magenta lines have been a flip zone for a very long time).
On the other hand Supply and Demand are a whole different breed, the more they are tested the weaker they become until eventually price take them out even by one pip and they're negated and removed. Usually to trade S&D, one would only rely on "fresh"(non tested) zone or tested only once...
On the picture you can see that older SD zones remain above and below the current swing.
As price goes down it removes Demand zones (outlined blue zone) and create new supply zone (solid red).
For me this indicator does not draw SD zones correctly and some of them are not even valid zone on the current TF. But higher TF zones are usually good enough, that's why I have posted this modified version that allow to display Higher TF SD zones automatically as you move through different TFs.
Hope that helps

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Wed May 26, 2021 8:13 am
by Meyney
schmurex wrote: Wed May 26, 2021 7:30 am Hi Meyney,
I think what you're after is a Support and Resistance indicator. The zone drawn on your chart is SR (see magenta lines on my chart)
As the theory goes, the more SR lines are tested the stronger they get, Price will eventually pass through and they would flip from S to R and the opposite, but they are not negated. (if you scroll back, the magenta lines have been a flip zone for a very long time).
On the other hand Supply and Demand are a whole different breed, the more they are tested the weaker they become until eventually price take them out even by one pip and they're negated and removed. Usually to trade S&D, one would only rely on "fresh"(non tested) zone or tested only once...
On the picture you can see that older SD zones remain above and below the current swing.
As price goes down it removes Demand zones (outlined blue zone) and create new supply zone (solid red).
For me this indicator does not draw SD zones correctly and some of them are not even valid zone on the current TF. But higher TF zones are usually good enough, that's why I have posted this modified version that allow to display Higher TF SD zones automatically as you move through different TFs.
Hope that helpsGY_M1250521.JPG
We have had already a few discussions here about SR and SD in this thread we know the difference, so perhaps scroll back to find out . Chart attached for you (SD not SR), hope this will help ;) Agree htf SD zones will certainly help. Also some SD zones will stay a little bit longer, will not vanish when they are taken out by one pip.

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Wed May 26, 2021 1:29 pm
by schmurex
Meyney wrote: Wed May 26, 2021 8:13 am We have had already a few discussions here about SR and SD in this thread we know the difference, so perhaps scroll back to find out . Chart attached for you (SD not SR), hope this will help ;) Agree htf SD zones will certainly help. Also some SD zones will stay a little bit longer, will not vanish when they are taken out by one pip.
Sorry I didn't see that discussion although I thought I had read the thread from the beginning. I probably missed it.
According to the code SD zones taken out will be removed at the next candle.
If you're looking at H1 SD zones on a M1 chart, next H1 candle might be a lot of of M1 candle away. I have tried to modify the code to get it removed right away but so far I didn't succeed.
I probably misunderstood your remark about the indicator plotting zones only when the direction is already made.... ;)

Re: Trading Pullbacks System

Posted: Wed May 26, 2021 7:20 pm
by Meyney
I probably misunderstood your remark about the indicator plotting zones only when the direction is already made.... ;)
[/quote]

Ah I see perhaps I was not clear. What I was trying to say: like this chart the big blue SD zone was not drawn by the indi but is important.