Page 74 of 213

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:09 am
by funchi
commodus wrote: Fri Jul 28, 2023 8:45 am
--------------
dear funchi
1-if the condtion of entry still met another trade is openning again, in following situations:
A- when manually closing a trade
B- when stop loss,take profit,trailing stop is closing a trade
C- when Exit condtions meet and entry is still meeting (for example i want to enter an up trend with MACD in 15 min but i prefer closing that trade with MACD in 5min time frame!) and in this situation after closing that trade, because of continueing the up trend in 15min,another trade will be open

All A-B-C are unpleasent situations and as you said, at now we have to define worse situations..

-----------------------

----------------------
2-As you know, crossing arrow option has its own weaknesses too:
a- usually its not the only or the last meeting condition for entry, and in these situations if you choose cross option, when the other condtions met(after passing X bars) it is gone and Entry signal will not appear
b- most of the idicators dont have this option
This is not my best system response, but I can't think of a good system response.
At any rate, this is a tentative system response, as I recognized the need for an urgent response.

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:11 am
by commodus
funchi wrote: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:00 am After the transaction is closed,
It is possible to set the parameter to not start trading for a certain period of time.

However, in this case,
If a second good signal occurs within a certain period of time, the entry opportunity will be missed.

Do you think it is good?


yess having this condtion as an option (with defineable time) really helps.
surely we want it :In Love:

also please, just take a look again at the secound way which i said yesterday, if it is applicable.. it solves the problem fundamentally and is not dependable to userdefined time
viewtopic.php?p=1295519396#p1295519396

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:14 am
by commodus
funchi wrote: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:09 am This is not my best system response, but I can't think of a good system response.
At any rate, this is a tentative system response, as I recognized the need for an urgent response.


take your time my friend. its not urgent. we are just cooperating for building an awsome frameworks for our froum :In Love:
hope it leads us to become millionaire :D

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:31 am
by funchi
commodus wrote: Thu Jul 27, 2023 7:00 am
2- if the Entry is showing up yet and in that period exit signal appears,the exit signal remains until the Entry signal dissapears.
I checked again with another translator.

I see.
Good idea.

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:42 am
by commodus
funchi wrote: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:00 am This is the only system response I can think of.

After the transaction is closed,
It is possible to set the parameter to not start trading for a certain period of time.

However, in this case,
If a second good signal occurs within a certain period of time, the entry opportunity will be missed.

Do you think it is good?

thank you my friend for taking time on reconsidering on that suggestions
i should recall that for following situations we still need a condtion like user defined time or another systematic method:
A- when manually closing a trade
B- when stop loss,take profit,trailing stop is closing a trade
in these situation we have not exit signal which stand againest continuing ENTRY signal

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 10:11 am
by funchi
funchi wrote: Fri Jul 28, 2023 9:31 am
commodus wrote: ↑
Thu Jul 27, 2023 6:00 am

2- if the Entry is showing up yet and in that period exit signal appears,the exit signal remains until the Entry signal dissapears.
I checked again with another translator.

I see.
Good idea.
Good ideas are misunderstood.
I think this system support is unnecessary.


Currently, the system will not make an entry after a certain period of time after an entry signal is displayed.
Past entry signals are ignored.
The initial value is 1 bar.
However, if it is within a certain period of time, it will re-enter.


The problem you all are having is,
Entry condition is met.
Exit condition is met.
Entry condition is met.
Exit condition met.
... Repeat in a short time.

I think this is it.

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 10:19 am
by funchi
commodus wrote: Fri Jul 28, 2023 8:45 am
--------------
dear funchi
1-if the condtion of entry still met another trade is openning again, in following situations:
A- when manually closing a trade
B- when stop loss,take profit,trailing stop is closing a trade
C- when Exit condtions meet and entry is still meeting (for example i want to enter an up trend with MACD in 15 min but i prefer closing that trade with MACD in 5min time frame!) and in this situation after closing that trade, because of continueing the up trend in 15min,another trade will be open
Is this true?
Especially the premise of 1.
Is it not a re-entry signal?

I would like to see the template.

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 10:25 am
by commodus
funchi wrote: Fri Jul 28, 2023 10:11 am Good ideas are misunderstood.
I think this system support is unnecessary.


Currently, the system will not make an entry after a certain period of time after an entry signal is displayed.
Past entry signals are ignored.
The initial value is 1 bar.
However, if it is within a certain period of time, it will re-enter.


The problem you all are having is,
Entry condition is met.
Exit condition is met.
Entry condition is met.
Exit condition met.
... Repeat in a short time.

I think this is it.
I think you are right sir. i seted that value higher than 1 because sometimes it didnet start positions when signals was appearing.
probably with value 1 and reconsidering the entry/exit modeling problem should solve
so I should check model of defining condtions again
thanks for giving clues and solutions <3

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 10:33 am
by commodus
as i thinking about it, we can:
step 1 ) define Entry signal which last just for 1 min
step 2) define a specific condition for Exit signal which is not seted in section of entry signals (set to not signal required in upper section)

this way we could have just one signal for entry and just one signal for cutting that trade :In Love:

Re: The FNC Greedy System

Posted: Fri Jul 28, 2023 2:16 pm
by funchi
Uploaded the latest version.
Please download from post #1.
Version 23.076

viewtopic.php?p=1295507591#p1295507591

Added the function "FNC_dashboard_EA_010".
Parameter "Trade pause time after trade closes (minutes)".
Default value is 240 minutes.
Sets the time to pause the trade after trade closes.

Rules
Works for each magic number, currency pair, and trade.
Even during the pause time, the trade is entered if there are different buy and sell.
Set to zero to disable.
This will affect the duration of the account history. (This is a specification of MT4. I won't go into details.)

This will not solve all problems.
There will be other problems.
Please post your problems.