newbietrader1 wrote: Tue Sep 02, 2025 3:00 am
Dear Mr funchi,
I have updated all the FNC_DB column and parameter as per attached. I also updated the FNC_DB_EA parameter too. I have not set any stop loss. I just only have few questions to ask. We don't talk about the Zee_SupRes and repainting issue first.
1) For USD CAD image, it triggers sell at Blue arrow. As I can see, there is no reason for it to trigger the sell, since all indicators are in up trend. If we refer to the red arrow, only the WAE, OBV is downtrend, but ADX and kingfisher indicator is still uptrend.
2) For USD CHF image, it triggers sell at Blue arrow. As I can see, there is no reason for it to trigger the sell, since all indicators are in up trend. If we refer to the red arrow, only the ADX, WAE, OBV is downtrend, but kingfisher indicator is still uptrend.
For trade to trigger, my settings for FNC_DB (WAE, OBV, ADX, KINGFISHER must be aligned, including Zee_SupRes, of course Zee_SupRes repaints.)
3) I was wondering is there any settings problem with the Kingfisher indicator? Is it better to use stochastic (2x) indicator instead? I will test it too.
4) As we can see the trade auto exit after certain points, I haven't set any stop loss at FNC_DB_EA, except the FNC_DB exit parameter, I set the signal match ratio for exit (GE%) to 80%, and 8th column (Zee S/R) for opposite direction. Why it exits that way?
5) I have noticed the entry time is always 7 seconds delay, is it normal?
Again, I'm sorry to ask a lot of questions again. Thank you for your patient Mr Funchi. Your reply is much appreciated.
> For USD CAD image, it triggers sell at Blue arrow. As I can see, there is no reason for it to trigger the sell, since all indicators are in up trend. If we refer to the red arrow, only the WAE, OBV is downtrend, but ADX and kingfisher indicator is still uptrend.
> For USD CHF image, it triggers sell at Blue arrow. As I can see, there is no reason for it to trigger the sell, since all indicators are in up trend. If we refer to the red arrow, only the ADX, WAE, OBV is downtrend, but kingfisher indicator is still uptrend.
We only know that a sell occurred, but we can't determine what the FNC_DB signals were at that time.
Assuming the trade was executed by FNC_DB's automated trading (a comment is usually added if FNC_DB places the trade),
if historical data is not fully loaded beforehand when launching FNC_DB, the signals are generated based on outdated data.
This is especially likely if you only use MT4 during the day, as historical data from the night may not be loaded.
Therefore, even if you start FNC_DB right after launching MT4 in the morning, it will not immediately display accurate signals.
FNC_DB’s entry conditions are not configured to require all signals to match.
It appears that only columns 1 to 5 are used to determine the signal.
As we can’t tell from the chart and FNC_DB column settings alone, I can’t say for certain,
but perhaps it was a legitimate sell entry?
Without both the chart template and the FNC_DB template, it’s not possible to investigate this accurately.
> As we can see the trade auto exit after certain points, I haven't set any stop loss at FNC_DB_EA, except the FNC_DB exit parameter, I set the signal match ratio for exit (GE%) to 80%, and 8th column (Zee S/R) for opposite direction. Why it exits that way?
I’m not sure which image you are referring to,
but regarding the signal ratio, please refer to my previous post.
As for Zee S/R, please refer to the answer in your post before last.
> I have noticed the entry time is always 7 seconds delay, is it normal?
Entries are executed as quickly as possible.
If the candlestick used for the signal is “1” (the previous one), the entry is made after the new candlestick appears and the signal is evaluated.
In a thin or quiet market, a delay of 7 seconds is possible.