funchi wrote: Thu Jan 04, 2024 11:48 pm The "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1" had good simulation results, so I actually ran the EA to find out if it was a redraw prank or the indicator's performance.

The results are good.

HeikenAshi is running the EA with SMA because of the redrawing.

The results of that picture are real life or backtest? If they are backtest would it be possible to test a larger time?

funchi wrote: Thu Jan 04, 2024 6:56 pm Indicator added.
FNC_Semafor_v1
FNC_2ndDot_v1
The signal was displayed as is as well as other redraw indicators.
For "XU v2-Arrow2" use "First 2nd dot" of "FNC_2ndDot_v1".

<Download>
In preparation.

Thank you for your great work. Your kindness is something only God can truly repay.

josi wrote: Fri Jan 05, 2024 12:19 am May I ask:
what were the indicator's inputs?
did you rely solely on RSI (or did you use other instruments for bias)?
when did you enter?
where was your SL?
when did you exit?

The only indicator is "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1".
The parameter values for the "FNC_RSI ma" indicator are default values.
However, HeikenAshi is redrawing, so I changed only there to closing price.
Started at the Tokyo market open on 1/5.
No SL/TP.
Only entry/exit signals in and out.

ffsss wrote: Fri Jan 05, 2024 7:29 am The results of that picture are real life or backtest? If they are backtest would it be possible to test a larger time?

On the left is the real one, starting from the Tokyo market open on 1/5.
The lower right side is the result of GBPAUD simulation for 53 days from 10/20.

My purpose this time is to check if "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1" is a redraw type.
It also serves as a validation of the simulation program.
If it turns out to be a redraw, I will stop it immediately.

I also plan to stop it if it does not show profit on a weekly basis.
So we plan to run it during the next week.

But in any case, if the results are good, we will add it to part of our trading strategy.

The "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1" indicator changed one previous state according to the current state.

This is so-called redrawing.
However, it is not clear if it redraws two or three previous states.

Redrawing is an excellent function depending on how it is used, as it immediately adapts to the market and updates the state, but it is not suitable for simulation.

Therefore, the verification of the "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1" indicator alone has been completed.

However, I think the performance of this indicator alone is good.
We would like to compare it with TDI in the future as we are using RSI.

I think the "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1" indicator does not redraw as far as I can see the logic of the program.

What do you think is going on?

Does it matter as long as the grades are good?
Are grades everything?

Uploaded the latest version (240.105).
The indicators that I have posted individually so far are included.
Please download from post #1.
viewtopic.php?p=1295507591#p1295507591


The simulation-related version has gone from alpha to beta.

funchi wrote: Fri Jan 05, 2024 9:10 am The only indicator is "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1".
The parameter values for the "FNC_RSI ma" indicator are default values.
However, HeikenAshi is redrawing, so I changed only there to closing price.
Started at the Tokyo market open on 1/5.
No SL/TP.
Only entry/exit signals in and out.

Does that mean:
you buy if price crosses 60 upwards?
you sell if price crosses 40 downwards?

(some people do it the other way round: they buy when price crosses 40 upwards and sell when it crosses 60 downwards)

and when exactly do you exit?

(many people use these limits for overbought vs oversold and would do the opposite - but I don't believe in the overbought vs oversold-nonsense, so I won't ask)

no SL - that may be very well in backtesting, but...

josi wrote: Fri Jan 05, 2024 7:14 pm Does that mean:
you buy if price crosses 60 upwards?
you sell if price crosses 40 downwards?

(some people do it the other way round: they buy when price crosses 40 upwards and sell when it crosses 60 downwards)

and when exactly do you exit?

(many people use these limits for overbought vs oversold and would do the opposite - but I don't believe in the overbought vs oversold-nonsense, so I won't ask)

no SL - that may be very well in backtesting, but...

This has already been posted,

I have determined that the "RSI ma simple+Arrows 1.1" indicator is a redraw type.
This is why the simulation results are better.

Do you still need an answer to your question?

funchi wrote: Fri Jan 05, 2024 7:44 pm Do you still need an answer to your question?

"This has already been posted,"
Actually, it hasn't - if you look at your post, you will see that my questions were not answered. Instead you assumed everyone knew exactly how you traded this indicator. But this - as my post tries to make clear - is not at all the case.
60/40
could mean anything: buy 60, sell 60, buy 40, sell 40 etc
If you can't see that those were valid questions, the answer is: no I don't need an answer to my questions