Page 2 of 4

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 1:12 am
by Intrest 1
I think that the trading system cannot be stupid. Only the rules of use can be stupid

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 1:54 am
by Forexlearner
Ogee wrote: Wed Jun 22, 2022 12:45 am having so many indicators will only conflict and not confirm. Indicators shouldn't be your starting point, your start point should be a repeatable 'setup', a candle pattern that crops up time and again and then find a couple of indicators that enhance the success ratio (positive expectancy) as proved by testing (back test then demo test then live test on minium bet size). Concentrate on 1 type of setup first and get real good at it before looking to expand.
point taken. thanks kind sir.

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 1:56 am
by Forexlearner
Intrest 1 wrote: Wed Jun 22, 2022 1:12 am I think that the trading system cannot be stupid. Only the rules of use can be stupid
i did some pretty stupid thing, mostly with repainting indicators, backtesting it was a sucess, That's why i was putting it that way.
I think none of this repaint, i did try to not do that mistake.

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 2:34 am
by Intrest 1
Forexlearner wrote: Wed Jun 22, 2022 1:56 am i did some pretty stupid thing, mostly with repainting indicators, backtesting it was a sucess, That's why i was putting it that way.
I think none of this repaint, i did try to not do that mistake.
There are people who win on repaint indicators, there are people who lose on non-repaint indicators.
When the logic of your trading system is correct, then what difference does it make according to which indicator to open a trade on a repainting one or on a non-repainting one? When the logic of the trading system is not correct,
then even the best non-repainting indicators will give a loss

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 2:37 am
by Intrest 1
Forexlearner wrote: Wed Jun 22, 2022 1:56 am i did some pretty stupid thing, mostly with repainting indicators, backtesting it was a sucess, That's why i was putting it that way.
I think none of this repaint, i did try to not do that mistake.
When you accurately determine the beginning of the price movement and the level of the end of the movement, you will win even with the help of a zigzag, which is considered to be repainting

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 2:50 am
by Tradehunter
First of all, what are you trying to do..
breakouts, ranges, trends, pullbacks, fade volatility?

How long can you hold a trade mentally?
Can you hold for a year, a month, a few hours or minutes before cutting it?
Are you going to sit in front of the screen and scalp or do you work 40 hours or more and have a family?

How many pairs or products are you going to trade?
28 forex? 4? 1?
The more products you trade the less you will be able to keep track of especially with indicators.
Try putting one of the 'hot' trading systems on here on 56 or even 28 pairs and see where that gets you.
You will be so inundated with signals and alerts you would be rendered basically impotent by all the noise.

Figure out what you want to do and most importantly what you can handle mentally.
If you are new to trading, plan on losing for a while till you figure it out because what you think you want to do vs what you can actually do are 2 disparate things.

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 10:03 pm
by Forexlearner
Intrest 1 wrote: Wed Jun 22, 2022 2:37 am When you accurately determine the beginning of the price movement and the level of the end of the movement, you will win even with the help of a zigzag, which is considered to be repainting
as a beginner i don't get how you can make a winning strategy based on repainting, something i tried searching and didn't found the answer

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 10:07 pm
by Forexlearner
Tradehunter wrote: Wed Jun 22, 2022 2:50 am First of all, what are you trying to do..
breakouts, ranges, trends, pullbacks, fade volatility?

How long can you hold a trade mentally?
Can you hold for a year, a month, a few hours or minutes before cutting it?
Are you going to sit in front of the screen and scalp or do you work 40 hours or more and have a family?

How many pairs or products are you going to trade?
28 forex? 4? 1?
The more products you trade the less you will be able to keep track of especially with indicators.
Try putting one of the 'hot' trading systems on here on 56 or even 28 pairs and see where that gets you.
You will be so inundated with signals and alerts you would be rendered basically impotent by all the noise.

Figure out what you want to do and most importantly what you can handle mentally.
If you are new to trading, plan on losing for a while till you figure it out because what you think you want to do vs what you can actually do are 2 disparate things.
trends especially, trying to enter a bit late on the crossover to get a confirmation, but not to late
Not very long, trying to get better at it
I started with scalping but trying to move to a trend based system, to hold until it turns, i can't stand in front of the screen all the time
EURUSD and GBPUSD but i try and see it any of the others are a good option

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Wed Jun 22, 2022 10:29 pm
by RplusT
Don't trade cross overs (often late in the game or misleading), trade pullbacks. Not difficult at all.

viewtopic.php?p=1295480975#p1295480975

Re: Tell me how stupid is my strategy

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2022 4:23 am
by Intrest 1
Forexlearner wrote: Wed Jun 22, 2022 10:03 pm as a beginner i don't get how you can make a winning strategy based on repainting, something i tried searching and didn't found the answer
To succeed in the market, you must learn to determine the purpose of the current movement. When you learn how to do this, then it will not matter to you what indicators to open deals in order to enter this movement.