kvak wrote: Mon Jun 17, 2024 4:45 am I am working on MT5 version of stepMA, but still is not good. Will see, if I am able to finish it....

Hi kvac, thank you again for all of your efforts.

I found an mt5 step indicator and posted in Cagliostro's thread for everyone's perusal. I am in no way any kind of coder, so I have no idea if this will help in your pursuit or not. With nothing but good intentions: post1295544250.html#p1295544250

DaveTrader wrote: Tue Jun 18, 2024 9:19 am Hi kvac, thank you again for all of your efforts.

I found an mt5 step indicator and posted in Cagliostro's thread for everyone's perusal. I am in no way any kind of coder, so I have no idea if this will help in your pursuit or not. With nothing but good intentions: post1295544250.html#p1295544250

Thanks, but I will work on my version, think is simplest....Main problems is when you switch from indices to indexes, you must use different settings....

kvak wrote: Mon Jun 17, 2024 4:45 am I am working on MT5 version of stepMA, but still is not good. Will see, if I am able to finish it....

are you kidding ? this is awesome ! I see only 1 losing trade

ionone wrote: Fri Jun 21, 2024 4:28 pm are you kidding ? this is awesome ! I see only 1 losing trade

Yes, this setup is good, but as I said, you must play with setting over different instruments....over weekend I post thus version....

Here is heiken ashi indicator with stepMA for test....
There is some methods to calculate "step" function. (atr/stdev, manually adjusted).

EDIT: I found bug in alerts,I forget to rewrite MT4 logic 1/-1 for logic in MT5 version. And alerts not working properly.

kvak wrote: Sun Jun 23, 2024 9:09 am Here is heiken ashi indicator with stepMA for test....
There is some methods to calculate "step" function. (atr/stdev, manually adjusted).

EDIT: I found bug in alerts,I forget to rewrite MT4 logic 1/-1 for logic in MT5 version. And alerts not working properly.

Who downloaded indicator, I upload new version in my original post.
I found bug in alerts. I am forget to rewrite MT4 logic 1/-1 for logic in MT5 version. And alerts not working properly.
Sorry for problems....

kvak wrote: Sun Jun 23, 2024 4:57 pm Who downloaded indicator, I upload new version in my original post.
I found bug in alerts. I am forget to rewrite MT4 logic 1/-1 for logic in MT5 version. And alerts not working properly.
Sorry for problems....

Really commend your efforts and expanding to also make codes for MT5 bro could you tell me I'm getting an error in the top left corner of MT5 saying: Error Copying Average True Range when I load the new Step indicator.... is it a bug or am I having problems with MT5?

boytoy wrote: Sun Jun 23, 2024 7:34 pm Really commend your efforts and expanding to also make codes for MT5 bro could you tell me I'm getting an error in the top left corner of MT5 saying: Error Copying Average True Range when I load the new Step indicator.... is it a bug or am I having problems with MT5?

I am start mql5 coding and some things are different from mql4 coding. I am not 100% sure why this error come ( maybe when market is off?)...but If I find any solution, I posted corrected version...

kvak wrote: Sun Jun 23, 2024 9:09 am Here is heiken ashi indicator with stepMA for test....
There is some methods to calculate "step" function. (atr/stdev, manually adjusted).

EDIT: I found bug in alerts,I forget to rewrite MT4 logic 1/-1 for logic in MT5 version. And alerts not working properly.

Big thanks @kvak for your efforts! It's not 1:1 matching with MT4 version but is very close, will test it extensively to verify if I can duplicate the trading system on MT5 with reasonably similar performances.

Could you add arrows in the future? Cheers.

Cagliostro wrote: Mon Jun 24, 2024 7:24 am Big thanks @kvak for your efforts! It's not 1:1 matching with MT4 version but is very close

Really good and clear comparison post man

kvak wrote: Mon Jun 24, 2024 1:19 am I am start mql5 coding and some things are different from mql4 coding. I am not 100% sure why this error come ( maybe when market is off?)...but If I find any solution, I posted corrected version...

Thank you for your attention Kvak.... you do so much for us traders already feel bad to ask for corrections/improvements but I know you will become a super MT5 coder too soon.... please hope we figure it out bro!!