Page 10 of 19

Re: Is this setup valuable? FS-17 by AI

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2025 3:41 am
by updowncrude

Gentlemen,

The three indicators you see in this picture are coded by AI.
I am just a monkey jumping one indicator to another all along been.


About the trading indicator:

Does RollingSwing100_EMA_FirstLabel_v2.mq4 Repaint?
No β€” it does not repaint, based on the logic you shared.

Here's why:

βœ… Only past bars are used for swing evaluation:

mql4
Copy
Edit
for (int j = checkBar - LookbackBars; j < checkBar; j++) {
if (High[checkBar] < High[j]) isHigh = false;

yaml
Copy
Edit
πŸ” It compares `checkBar` to **earlier bars only** β€” not future ones.

2. βœ… **Swing labels and arrows are fixed** once printed:
- The swing point is confirmed the moment the current bar closes and **remains untouched**.
- The buffer writes to `checkBar`, not future bars.

3. βœ… Uses **non-centered, backward-only** confirmation logic:
- No lookahead like `high[i+1]`, `low[i+2]`, etc.
- Therefore, **zero repainting** from lookahead errors.

---

## 🟑 What It Does Not Do:

- It does **not** wait for confirmation (like ZigZag with 2 future bars), so:
- You may get **early swing signals**, and some may be close to the actual pivot but not perfect.
- This is **expected** in non-repainting indicators β€” a good tradeoff.

---

## βœ… Can You Use It in Live Trading?

Yes β€” it's **safe for live trading**, as long as:
- You **understand** it's showing **"real-time" swing highs/lows** based only on history
- You combine it with:
- Trend filters (e.g., 200 EMA)
- Structure-based confirmation (e.g., HH/HL or LH/LL)
- Entry/exit rules (e.g., engulfing, breakout, RSI)

It’s especially good for:
- **Swing high/low trailing**
- Confirming reversals without fear of repaints
- Entry signals on strong breakouts from a swing

---

Re: Is this setup valuable? FS-17 by AI

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2025 5:39 am
by Kjamie993
updowncrude wrote: Wed Jun 11, 2025 3:41 am FS-17 ( AI ).PNG


Gentlemen,

The three indicators you see in this picture are coded by AI.
I am just a monkey jumping one indicator to another all along been.


About the trading indicator:

Does RollingSwing100_EMA_FirstLabel_v2.mq4 Repaint?
No β€” it does not repaint, based on the logic you shared.

Here's why:

βœ… Only past bars are used for swing evaluation:

mql4
Copy
Edit
for (int j = checkBar - LookbackBars; j < checkBar; j++) {
if (High[checkBar] < High[j]) isHigh = false;

yaml
Copy
Edit
πŸ” It compares `checkBar` to **earlier bars only** β€” not future ones.

2. βœ… **Swing labels and arrows are fixed** once printed:
- The swing point is confirmed the moment the current bar closes and **remains untouched**.
- The buffer writes to `checkBar`, not future bars.

3. βœ… Uses **non-centered, backward-only** confirmation logic:
- No lookahead like `high[i+1]`, `low[i+2]`, etc.
- Therefore, **zero repainting** from lookahead errors.

---

## 🟑 What It Does Not Do:

- It does **not** wait for confirmation (like ZigZag with 2 future bars), so:
- You may get **early swing signals**, and some may be close to the actual pivot but not perfect.
- This is **expected** in non-repainting indicators β€” a good tradeoff.

---

## βœ… Can You Use It in Live Trading?

Yes β€” it's **safe for live trading**, as long as:
- You **understand** it's showing **"real-time" swing highs/lows** based only on history
- You combine it with:
- Trend filters (e.g., 200 EMA)
- Structure-based confirmation (e.g., HH/HL or LH/LL)
- Entry/exit rules (e.g., engulfing, breakout, RSI)

It’s especially good for:
- **Swing high/low trailing**
- Confirming reversals without fear of repaints
- Entry signals on strong breakouts from a swing

---
Great work and effort here! Impressive posts and results with explanations. Hats off to you! I’d appreciate if you would share

RollingSwing100_EMA_FirstLabel_v2.mq4

This will allow other users to perform their own in depth testing and results and use other indicators to create a unique system we can all benefits from!

Kind Regards
K

Re: Is this setup valuable?

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2025 3:20 pm
by ALTKUB
could you share FS-17 ?

Regards

Re: Is this setup valuable? AI -FS-01

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2025 10:48 pm
by updowncrude
Isnt this candle moved swiftly as per instrument ?

Re: Is this setup valuable? AI -FS-01

Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2025 3:51 am
by updowncrude
Which time frame is best to trade ?

The foremost question of the trader on any setup.

Is it possible to embed 15M signals on 30M chart differentiating the signals with pricetags to place a reversal order
on broken swing ?

I do not know.

I engaged Chatgpt with my logic and conditions.

It gave me an output.

Check the picture.
30M signals with arrows and price , 15M signals no arrows, only price.
Price tags help us to place reversal order.
The logic ensures chances of repainting in 30M signals are rare,
Opportunities to book profits is a must feature,15M signals help.



In the following picture, you can see atleast one 15M swing signal high is broken,
but many times enable to book profits and re-enter.



Re: Is this setup valuable? AI -FS-01

Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2025 4:26 am
by Kjamie993
updowncrude wrote: Thu Jun 12, 2025 3:51 am Which time frame is best to trade ?

The foremost question of the trader on any setup.

Is it possible to embed 15M signals on 30M chart differentiating the signals with pricetags to place a reversal order
on broken swing ?

I do not know.

I engaged Chatgpt with my logic and conditions.

It gave me an output.

Check the picture.
30M signals with arrows and price , 15M signals no arrows, only price.
Price tags help us to place reversal order.
The logic ensures chances of repainting in 30M signals are rare,
Opportunities to book profits is a must feature,15M signals help.


AI-FS-01.PNG 2.PNG



In the following picture, you can see atleast one 15M swing signal high is broken,
but many times enable to book profits and re-enter.



AI-FS-01.PNG 3.PNG
Please can you share the indicators you are showing in screenshots? Multiple people are seeking to use these to assist in creating a system.

Thank you

Re: Is this setup valuable? Moved to MT5

Posted: Thu Jun 19, 2025 10:04 am
by updowncrude
This thread will engage MT5, hereafter.

Re: Is this setup valuable? Moved to MT5

Posted: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:40 pm
by mate
updowncrude wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 10:04 am This thread will engage MT5, hereafter.

It looks like an ordinary TMA channel, there are already hundreds of them here)

Re: Is this setup valuable? Moved to MT5

Posted: Thu Jun 19, 2025 10:32 pm
by updowncrude
mate wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:40 pm It looks like an ordinary TMA channel, there are already hundreds of them here)
just started, find this running in realtime,confluence of indicators.

Re: Is this setup valuable? Moved to MT5

Posted: Thu Jun 19, 2025 11:48 pm
by Cagliostro
mate wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:40 pm It looks like an ordinary TMA channel, there are already hundreds of them here)
Yaeh, same idea, repainting bands with fake stats. Do you want one? I have dozens... look, this is a system I made and never published. Love the stats?
And these are real bands, not TMA, ATR BB.