Page 1 of 3
Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 4:15 am
by AnGe335
Hello,
ihm searching for really non repainting bands, price channel indicators and so on for findig good entries in trend direction.
ihm experimenting around with TMA+CG NRP versions from Mladen and Teamtrader but they are also repaints the last 3-4 candles in my settings (half length 15, deviations 2.618).
As example: I want to enter a short position when the price is below a 100 EMA channel (1 calculated on highs, the other EMA is calculated on the lows) and want to find an entry in a Retracement of the actual short movement - therefor i need reliable bands which does not repaint... I´ve tried envelopes, TMA+CG and so on but nothing delivers really good results. The best result would deliver the TMA+CG versions but the problem is, they sometimes show entries and then correct their drawing and the entry was way to early.
I also commend it with a very fast configured MFI (period 3) but this keeps me out of the good signals to often and does not really filter the bad ones.
Any ides mates?
Cheers, Andi
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:39 am
by jng640
AnGe335 wrote: Thu Sep 30, 2021 4:15 am
Hello,
ihm searching for really non repainting bands, price channel indicators and so on for findig good entries in trend direction.
ihm experimenting around with TMA+CG NRP versions from Mladen and Teamtrader but they are also repaints the last 3-4 candles in my settings (half length 15, deviations 2.618).
As example: I want to enter a short position when the price is below a 100 EMA channel (1 calculated on highs, the other EMA is calculated on the lows) and want to find an entry in a Retracement of the actual short movement - therefor i need reliable bands which does not repaint... I´ve tried envelopes, TMA+CG and so on but nothing delivers really good results. The best result would deliver the TMA+CG versions but the problem is, they sometimes show entries and then correct their drawing and the entry was way to early.
I also commend it with a very fast configured MFI (period 3) but this keeps me out of the good signals to often and does not really filter the bad ones.
Any ides mates?
Cheers, Andi
Those Centered TMA indicator will keep recalculate the outcome. Try to create another type of trading system.
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:50 am
by charli
I have this one, shared by Reteid2222, but I think it is only lwma, as we all know tma can not be without recalc. tma looks perfect but better get a divorce with that girl mate :-) and find another one as jng640 said
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:59 am
by jng640
charli wrote: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:50 am
I have this one, shared by Reteid2222, but I think it is only lwma, as we all know tma can not be without recalc. tma looks perfect but better get a divorce with that girl mate :-) and find another one as jng640 said
centered tma bands without recalculate the outcome will not get the "Holy Grail" result
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:01 am
by charli
I am trying as well with a version that i posted, but need some filters of course....This picture looks promising, but let's test it first and I will get back to you...
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:08 am
by charli
jng640 wrote: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:59 am
centered tma bands without recalculate the outcome will not get the "Holy Grail" result
Exactly, so it is not possible, "swingman" from another forum describe this as play with it big time also, who is interested can google it swingman tma
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:31 am
by Banzai
ALMA ATR Channel
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:33 am
by Banzai
HMA ATR Channel
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 1:29 pm
by Banzai
Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 1:38 pm
by Banzai
TMA ATR Channel repaint
This one repaints. Unfortunately.