Page 1 of 3

Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 4:15 am
by AnGe335
Hello,

ihm searching for really non repainting bands, price channel indicators and so on for findig good entries in trend direction.
ihm experimenting around with TMA+CG NRP versions from Mladen and Teamtrader but they are also repaints the last 3-4 candles in my settings (half length 15, deviations 2.618).

As example: I want to enter a short position when the price is below a 100 EMA channel (1 calculated on highs, the other EMA is calculated on the lows) and want to find an entry in a Retracement of the actual short movement - therefor i need reliable bands which does not repaint... I´ve tried envelopes, TMA+CG and so on but nothing delivers really good results. The best result would deliver the TMA+CG versions but the problem is, they sometimes show entries and then correct their drawing and the entry was way to early.

I also commend it with a very fast configured MFI (period 3) but this keeps me out of the good signals to often and does not really filter the bad ones. :think:

Any ides mates?
Cheers, Andi

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:39 am
by jng640
AnGe335 wrote: Thu Sep 30, 2021 4:15 am Hello,

ihm searching for really non repainting bands, price channel indicators and so on for findig good entries in trend direction.
ihm experimenting around with TMA+CG NRP versions from Mladen and Teamtrader but they are also repaints the last 3-4 candles in my settings (half length 15, deviations 2.618).

As example: I want to enter a short position when the price is below a 100 EMA channel (1 calculated on highs, the other EMA is calculated on the lows) and want to find an entry in a Retracement of the actual short movement - therefor i need reliable bands which does not repaint... I´ve tried envelopes, TMA+CG and so on but nothing delivers really good results. The best result would deliver the TMA+CG versions but the problem is, they sometimes show entries and then correct their drawing and the entry was way to early.

I also commend it with a very fast configured MFI (period 3) but this keeps me out of the good signals to often and does not really filter the bad ones. :think:

Any ides mates?
Cheers, Andi
Those Centered TMA indicator will keep recalculate the outcome. Try to create another type of trading system.

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:50 am
by charli
I have this one, shared by Reteid2222, but I think it is only lwma, as we all know tma can not be without recalc. tma looks perfect but better get a divorce with that girl mate :-) and find another one as jng640 said

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:59 am
by jng640
charli wrote: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:50 am I have this one, shared by Reteid2222, but I think it is only lwma, as we all know tma can not be without recalc. tma looks perfect but better get a divorce with that girl mate :-) and find another one as jng640 said
centered tma bands without recalculate the outcome will not get the "Holy Grail" result :Rofl:

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:01 am
by charli
I am trying as well with a version that i posted, but need some filters of course....This picture looks promising, but let's test it first and I will get back to you...

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:08 am
by charli
jng640 wrote: Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:59 am centered tma bands without recalculate the outcome will not get the "Holy Grail" result :Rofl:
Exactly, so it is not possible, "swingman" from another forum describe this as play with it big time also, who is interested can google it swingman tma

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:31 am
by Banzai
ALMA ATR Channel

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:33 am
by Banzai
HMA ATR Channel

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 1:29 pm
by Banzai

Re: Are there any REALLY NON REPAINTING Bands out there?

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2021 1:38 pm
by Banzai
TMA ATR Channel repaint

This one repaints. Unfortunately.