Judging by older versions of up-down, the signal disappears after a new extremum appears. Places of old transactions are marked in the squares. Pictures taken from another forum discussing this indicator

This is based on an ancient indicator called Peak Repaint

wojtek wrote: Sun Dec 24, 2023 4:13 pm That's correct, but he has been there with some activity since 2011.
I'm not on anyone's side, just a fact.

Yeah that is a valid point and has not been banned from there

Intrest 1 wrote: Sun Dec 24, 2023 6:47 pm This is based on an ancient indicator called Peak Repaint

This decompiled one? Couldn't find a legit version

i just try your indicator on demo version, i don't know yet is this good or not,
but one thing for sure, the visual of this indicator is very poor, some times the signals appear, after a while it disappear.
if you want to sell something please make sure the visual output of the indicator already fix, you can see the example of vertex indicator (the non repaint one). because i saw yours is looks like it.
after you fix the visual then it will be easier to spot the repaint or not.
Regards,

boytoy wrote: Sun Dec 24, 2023 8:30 pm This decompiled one? Couldn't find a legit version

I can't tell you where to find the source code for the Peak Repainter indicator, but any version of Vertex that redraws is based on this. There are no fundamental differences between them

There is not vertex indicator on Web, that no repaint.
All wertex are repaints.
My up down indicator sometimes need to press + button to see signal. Because it use Exp. Values, so that indicator Values reach too high Values.
it is no repaint.
But after any values, if it comes too high value
That makes before insible.

But it is there still if you press + button you can see it.
Yes sometimes signal comes again.
That is drawdown. Not repaint.
But if you wait buy and buy again, you sell higher point to win.
In forex you have to high margin to win.
And you have to look one step up timeframe for the trend direction.
I am working more than 20 years in forex and indicator coding.

now i developped thise indicator.
up down gold
no repaint and almost holly grail.

gold daily chart

gold daily chart..
up down gold indicator
gold buy signal comes here...


THISE WILL BE NEW TOPIC ISSUE..BUT LATER
now for either share,nor sell.....

btc daily chart
up down gold indicator